
Reach for this book when your child is suffering from the acute embarrassment that defines the preteen years or when they feel they lack a feminine roadmap for growing up. Alice McKinley is a motherless sixth grader who is convinced she is the only person on earth who consistently makes a fool of herself. In her quest to find a perfect, beautiful role model to help her navigate puberty and social graces, she finds herself assigned to the classroom of a teacher she considers plain and uninspiring. The story gently explores themes of self-worth, the fallacy of perfection, and the realization that a person's value lies in their character rather than their appearance. It is a compassionate and often hilarious look at the awkward transition into middle school that helps children see that even their most cringeworthy moments are a normal part of being human.
The book deals with the death of a mother, but the event is in the past. Alice's grief is presented as a longing for guidance rather than acute trauma. The approach is secular and realistic. It also touches on puberty and physical development in a direct, matter-of-fact way.
A 10 or 11-year-old girl who feels like she is 'doing life wrong' or who is worried about the changes coming with middle school and puberty.
Read cold. Parents should be aware there are brief, frank mentions of bra-shopping and menstruation. A child expressing deep shame over a minor social mistake or a daughter asking questions about her late mother or feminine development that feel heavy.
Younger readers (9-10) focus on the slapstick humor of Alice's mistakes. Older readers (11-13) connect more deeply with her search for identity and the fear of social judgment.
Naylor captures the specific 'agony' of pre-teen embarrassment with a precision and warmth that few other authors achieve, making it a timeless 'mirror' book for girls.
Alice McKinley is starting sixth grade and is tired of her reputation for doing embarrassing things. Living in a house with only her father and older brother, she feels the absence of her mother deeply as she approaches puberty. She decides she needs a glamorous role model and sets her sights on a beautiful teacher, Miss Cole. However, she is placed in the class of Mrs. Plotkins, who is messy and unglamorous. Through a series of social mishaps and honest conversations, Alice learns that Mrs. Plotkins possesses the depth and empathy she truly needs.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review


















