
Reach for this book when your teenager is grappling with the complexities of justice, the impact of snap decisions, or the nuances of gender identity. It is an essential tool for parents who want to move beyond headlines to discuss how race, class, and bias intersect in the real world. Dashka Slater provides a compassionate, multi-perspective look at a true event where a nonbinary teen was harmed by a Black teenager on an Oakland bus. The narrative explores restorative justice and accountability through the lens of two very different lives. It tackles heavy themes like systemic racism and transphobia with clinical precision and deep empathy. While the subject matter is intense, it offers a vital framework for understanding that people are more than the worst thing they have ever done, making it ideal for mature middle and high schoolers.
A character is set on fire; detailed descriptions of third-degree burns and skin grafts.
Severe physical violence (a hate crime involving fire), graphic descriptions of third-degree burns and medical procedures, systemic racism within the juvenile justice system, and incarceration.
A thoughtful teenager (14 plus) who is interested in social justice or law, particularly one who is ready to move beyond 'good vs. evil' narratives to understand how systemic racism and transphobia can impact the justice system.
Parents should preview Part 2 (The Fire) and Part 3 (The Hospital). The descriptions of Sasha's injuries and the physical pain of the recovery process are visceral and may be difficult for sensitive readers. The book can be read cold by older teens, but benefit from discussion regarding the legal definitions of hate crimes. A child comes home asking why a person would commit a hate crime, or perhaps expressing frustration and anger after seeing news reports about juvenile crime or systemic bias.
Younger teens (12-14) will likely focus on the immediate injustice of the act and the physical recovery. Older teens (15-18) will better grasp the meta-narrative regarding how the media and the court system shape our perception of 'victims' and 'criminals.'
Unlike many books that focus solely on the victim, Slater provides an incredibly balanced view of both teenagers. It refuses to demonize the perpetrator or pathologize the victim, instead using both lives to critique the systems that fail them both.
This journalistic nonfiction account tracks the 2013 true story of two teenagers, Sasha and Richard, whose lives collide when Richard sets Sasha's skirt on fire on an Oakland bus. Sasha is nonbinary, and Richard is Black, and the book explores how race and gender identity played a role in the crime and its aftermath. The book follows the legal aftermath, the recovery process, and the systemic forces surrounding both boys.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review