
Reach for this book when your child starts questioning the absolute definitions of heroism and villainy, or when they are struggling with a bully and need to understand the hidden burdens others might carry. Set during World War II, the story follows eleven-year-old Margaret as she navigates the complexities of home-front loyalty. What begins as a simple tale of avoiding a neighborhood bully transforms into a profound exploration of empathy when Margaret discovers that her tormentor, Gordy, is secretly caring for his brother, a deserter hiding in the woods. This novel is a masterclass in emotional nuance, perfect for the 9 to 13 age range. It moves beyond black and white morality to show how fear and love can lead people to make difficult, sometimes illegal, choices. Parents will appreciate how it handles heavy themes like domestic abuse and the ethics of war with grace and historical accuracy, providing a safe space to discuss why good people sometimes do 'bad' things and why 'cowardice' isn't always what it seems.
Suspenseful scenes involving hiding from authorities and angry parents.
Themes of war, loss of loved ones, and the cycles of poverty and abuse.
Realistic depictions of domestic abuse and a father hitting his children.
The book deals directly and realistically with domestic abuse (Gordy's father is a violent alcoholic) and the psychological toll of war. The resolution is bittersweet and realistic: Stuart turns himself in, and while there is hope for Gordy's future, the trauma of his home life is not magically erased.
A middle-schooler who enjoys historical fiction but is ready for 'gray area' stories. Specifically, a child who has noticed that people who act out often have difficult lives behind the scenes and wants to explore the concept of radical empathy.
Parents should be aware of the depictions of child abuse. Gordy is beaten by his father, and the descriptions, while age-appropriate, are visceral. Reading the chapters where Stuart explains his reasons for deserting can help prepare for a conversation on pacifism. A child expressing a very rigid 'us vs. them' mentality, or a child who is confused by the news of soldiers or citizens who disagree with a popular conflict.
Younger readers (9-10) will focus on the suspense of the secret hideout and the shift in the bullying dynamic. Older readers (11-13) will grasp the political and ethical weight of Stuart’s desertion vs. Margaret’s brother's service.
Unlike many WWII books that focus on the glory of the front lines or the tragedy of the Holocaust, this focuses on the moral conflict of the home front and the 'invisible' victims of war, like deserters and their families.
In 1944 Maryland, Margaret and Elizabeth spend their days dodging Gordy, the local bully. Their perspective shifts when they discover Gordy is hiding his older brother, Stuart, who has deserted the Army. As the girls help Gordy provide for Stuart, they confront the reality of Gordy’s abusive father and the moral dilemma of supporting a 'traitor' while Margaret’s own brother fights overseas.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review