
Reach for this book when your child is navigating a major life transition, such as moving to a new city, or when they begin asking complex questions about fairness, history, and why people are treated differently based on their identity. Set in 1947, the story follows ten-year-old Sally as she moves from New Jersey to Florida, leaving her father behind while her brother recovers from an illness. It is a masterclass in how children process the heavy realities of the world through the lens of their own imagination and daily concerns. Sally is a vibrant, imaginative protagonist who grapples with the lingering shadows of World War II, including her fear that a neighbor might be a hidden Adolf Hitler. The book beautifully balances the lighthearted trials of making new friends and dealing with school lice with serious themes of antisemitism and Jim Crow segregation. It serves as a gentle but honest bridge for parents to discuss historical injustice and the way empathy develops during the pre-teen years. It is best suited for readers aged 8 to 12 who are ready for a nuanced look at both personal and social history.
Sally's vivid fantasies about Nazis can be tense for sensitive readers.
The book depicts instances of racism, including segregation and discriminatory practices like 'colored' water fountains, which may be upsetting to some readers. It also touches on antisemitism, potentially sparking conversations about prejudice and discrimination. Sally experiences intense fears related to the Holocaust, expressed through her imagination. These fears, while fantastical, are rooted in the very real trauma of historical events and may be disturbing to some readers. The approach is realistic and secular, grounded in the perspective of a Jewish child in 1947.
An inquisitive 9 or 10-year-old who feels things deeply and possesses a 'dramatic' or highly imaginative personality. It is perfect for a child who is starting to notice social injustices and needs a character who shares their sense of moral outrage.
Parents should be prepared to discuss Jim Crow laws and the Holocaust, as the book depicts these historical realities and their impact on Sally's experiences and fears. Specifically, the scene where Sally is pulled away from a water fountain requires historical context about the era's 'separate but equal' fallacies. A parent might see their child reacting with intense confusion or anger to a news story about discrimination, or perhaps witnessing their child struggle to fit into a new social circle after a move.
Younger readers (8-9) will focus on the school drama, the lice incident, and the sibling dynamics. Older readers (11-12) will better grasp the historical weight of Sally's 'Hitler' fantasies and the systemic nature of the racism she witnesses.
Unlike many historical novels that feel stiff, Blume captures the internal 'monologue' of a child with total authenticity. It’s unique for how it shows a child using Hollywood-inspired fantasies to cope with genuine historical trauma. """
In the aftermath of WWII, Sally Freedman moves with her mother, grandmother, and sick brother to Miami. While her father stays in New Jersey for work, Sally navigates a new school, the social hierarchy of 1940s Florida, and her own vivid daydreams. She encounters the harsh reality of segregation and processes the trauma of the Holocaust by projecting her fears onto a local neighbor she suspects is Hitler in disguise.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review