
Reach for this book when your teen is struggling with the pressure of online performance or has made a mistake that snowballled out of control. It is a comedic yet poignant exploration of how a small lie, intended to cover up a failed science experiment, can turn into a viral sensation that tests family bonds. Gideon and his brother Caleb find themselves in over their heads when they claim a crater in a cornfield is the work of aliens. The story dives deep into themes of honesty, the ethics of social media, and the complicated dynamics of sibling loyalty. Parents will appreciate the way it handles Gideon's identity as a gay teen with normalcy, focusing instead on his character growth and the weight of his choices. It is a perfect choice for high schoolers who enjoy witty humor but need a gentle reminder about the value of truth in a world obsessed with fame.
Protagonists engage in a sustained, public lie that affects their entire community.
Brief mentions of teenage parties and social drinking.
None.
A 15-year-old who feels like they have to be extraordinary to be noticed. This is for the teen who has ever felt the crushing weight of a "white lie" that spiraled out of control, or for someone navigating the gap between who they are online and who they are at home.
This book can be read cold. Parents may want to discuss the ethics of the brothers' deception, but the narrative does a heavy lift in showing the consequences of their actions without being preachy. A parent might notice their child becoming increasingly secretive about their digital life or expressing deep anxiety over a mistake they feel they cannot fix. It is the perfect response to a teen saying, "I've messed everything up and I don't know how to tell the truth now."
Younger teens (13-14) will likely focus on the high-stakes comedy and the thrill of the prank. Older teens (16-18) will resonate more with the existential dread of being "found out" and the nuanced portrayal of Gideon's desire for academic and social validation.
Unlike many YA novels that treat a character's sexuality as the primary conflict, this book presents Gideon's identity as a settled fact. The real story here is a refreshing, character-driven comedy about the absurdity of internet fame and the enduring, often messy, bond between brothers.
Gideon is a high schooler obsessed with winning a science competition. When a homemade explosive creates a massive crater in a neighbor's cornfield, he and his brother Caleb panic and invent an alien encounter to avoid legal trouble. The lie goes viral, turning their quiet town into a hub for UFO enthusiasts and testing the brothers' relationship as the deception grows too large to contain.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review