Families who loved Return to the Carnival of Horrors by R. L. Stine often look for books with a similar feel. These 20 recommendations were selected for their similarity in style, theme, and reading level.
A parent would reach for this book when they have a reluctant reader who craves agency and excitement or a child who enjoys the thrill of being scared within a safe, controlled environment. This interactive adventure places the reader at the center of the story, forcing them to make high stakes choices to escape a supernatural carnival. While the atmosphere is spooky, the primary focus is on logic, problem solving, and the fun of trial and error. It is a fantastic tool for building reading stamina in elementary schoolers because the short segments and multiple paths keep them constantly engaged. Through its horror themed puzzles, the book subtly encourages resilience, as making a 'wrong' choice is simply part of the game. It is a playful, safe way for children to explore fear and decision making while feeling like they are in total control of the narrative.
