Families who loved On Meeting Witches at Wells by Judith Gorog often look for books with a similar feel. These 20 recommendations were selected for their similarity in style, theme, and reading level.

Reach for this book when your middle schooler is craving stories that linger in the mind long after lights out, or when they are showing an interest in the darker, more mysterious side of folklore. This collection is perfect for a rainy afternoon or a camping trip, offering a sophisticated alternative to typical jump-scare horror. It centers on a group of students trapped at school during a blizzard, sharing eerie tales to pass the time. While the framing device is familiar, the stories themselves are haunting and atmospheric, exploring themes of bravery, the consequences of curiosity, and the thin line between reality and the supernatural. The prose is elegant and challenging, making it an excellent choice for advanced readers who appreciate psychological depth and folkloric tradition rather than gore. It provides a safe space for children to explore fear and the unknown through the lens of timeless storytelling.