Families who loved Karen's Baby-Sitter by Ann M. Martin often look for books with a similar feel. These 20 recommendations were selected for their similarity in style, theme, and reading level.
Reach for this book when your child is starting to push for more independence but still struggles with the separation anxiety of a parent going out for the night. Karen Brewer is a relatable, spunky protagonist who deals with the common childhood dilemma of wanting to be a 'big kid' while feeling intimidated by a new authority figure in the house. The story beautifully captures the nuance of blended family life and the 'two-house' experience. Through Karen's perspective, children see that it is normal to feel nervous about change or new people. The book models how to handle those big feelings with humor and honesty. It is an excellent choice for early elementary readers transitioning into chapter books, offering a gentle way to discuss rules, boundaries, and the fact that a babysitter can actually be a source of fun rather than just a replacement for Mom or Dad.