Families who loved Tales of Goodly Might by Eric K. Barnum often look for books with a similar feel. These 20 recommendations were selected for their similarity in style, theme, and reading level.

Reach for this book when your middle-schooler is grappling with the weight of their mistakes or struggling to understand how a person can change for the better. These high-fantasy stories serve as a powerful metaphor for the internal struggle between our darker impulses and our desire to do good. Through four distinct vignettes involving knights, angels, and even a fallen anti-paladin, the book explores themes of redemption, spiritual warfare, and the courage required to stand against peer pressure or corrupt authority. While the setting is filled with monsters and magic, the emotional core focuses on the transformative power of forgiveness and the hope that it is never too late to choose a different path. It is an ideal pick for families who appreciate traditional moral storytelling and epic adventures with a clear sense of purpose.