Families who loved Cat in Glass, and Other Tales of the Unnatural by Nancy Etchemendy often look for books with a similar feel. These 20 recommendations were selected for their similarity in style, theme, and reading level.
Reach for this collection when your teenager is feeling alienated by the world or is beginning to grapple with the heavier, darker realities of the human experience. Through eight uncanny tales, Nancy Etchemendy uses the lens of horror and the supernatural to explore very real feelings of isolation, physical difference, and existential dread. It is a sophisticated choice for young readers who find comfort in the 'weird' rather than the 'wholesome.' While the stories touch on intense subjects like suicide, nuclear war, and madness, they are handled with a literary touch that prioritizes psychological depth over cheap thrills. These narratives validate a teen's sense of being an outsider while subtly weaving in themes of resilience and self-preservation. It is a safe, metaphorical space for mature middle schoolers and high schoolers to process complex emotions and the darker corners of the imagination.
