
Reach for this book if your teenager is struggling with the heavy, circular thoughts of 'if only' following a significant loss. This story addresses the visceral guilt and shame that often accompany grief, particularly when a final interaction was left unresolved or angry. Harriet, a Nigerian-American high schooler, believes she is responsible for her brother's death and finds herself drawn to a mysterious girl who promises a way to change the past. While the narrative touches on speculative elements, it is deeply rooted in the realistic emotional landscape of depression and social isolation. It offers a sophisticated look at self-forgiveness and the courage it takes to live in the reality of the present rather than the fantasy of a redo. Suitable for ages 12 and up, this is a compassionate choice for parents wanting to validate their child's complex feelings while gently steering them toward healing.
Atmospheric tension and some danger within the surreal underground setting.
Pervasive themes of sibling death, grief, and clinical depression.
The book deals directly with the death of a sibling and the resulting clinical depression and survivor's guilt. The approach is a blend of gritty realism and metaphorical speculative fiction. The resolution is realistic and hopeful, emphasizing that healing isn't about erasing the past but learning to carry it.
A thoughtful 13 to 16 year old who feels like an outsider and is navigating the 'messy' side of grief: the anger, the guilt, and the social awkwardness that follows a tragedy.
Parents should be aware of the intense depictions of depression and the allure of a 'perfect' world that acts as a metaphor for suicidal ideation or total withdrawal from reality. It is best read with an open line of communication. A parent might notice their child withdrawing, obsessing over past conversations, or expressing a desire to simply 'not be here' or to 'fix' things that cannot be changed.
Younger teens will focus on the mystery of the 'Underneath' and the friendship dynamics, while older teens will more deeply resonate with the philosophical questions about memory and the ethics of changing one's history.
Unlike many grief novels that focus on the 'stages' of loss, this book uses speculative fiction to externalize the internal battle of guilt, making the abstract feeling of 'wanting a redo' into a tangible, dangerous choice.
Harriet Adu is paralyzed by the 'what-if' thoughts following her brother's death, carrying the secret weight of their last argument. When a mysterious new student named Sima introduces her to a hidden, surreal world beneath the New York City subway system, Harriet is offered the chance to access a different reality where she can undo her mistakes. The story follows her journey through the 'Underneath' as she grapples with the lure of a second chance versus the painful necessity of grieving in the real world.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review