
Reach for this book when your teenager is processing the complicated grief of losing a sibling, especially when that relationship was strained by mental health challenges or a sense of 'caregiver burnout.' This story explores the bond between two sisters, Jane and Lily. Jane struggled with a mental illness that blurred the lines between reality and her make-believe world, often leaving Lily to play the role of the mature protector. Now that Jane is gone, Lily must navigate the heavy guilt of moving forward while Jane remains 'stuck' in her own spectral reality. It is a poignant choice for families needing to validate the messy, often contradictory feelings of relief and profound loss that come with a family member's long-term illness. While the narrative includes a haunting, supernatural element, its heart is firmly rooted in the realistic emotional labor of sisterhood and the difficult process of letting go. Suitable for mature middle schoolers and high school students, it provides a safe space to discuss the impact of mental health on the entire family unit.
Heavy focus on grief, mental illness, and the loss of childhood innocence.
Ghostly occurrences and a haunting atmosphere throughout.
The book portrays the impact of mental illness and death on a family with realistic and sometimes painful detail. Lily experiences grief, confusion, and resentment, which may be upsetting for some readers. While there are 'ghostly' elements, the focus is on the psychological weight of these events. The resolution is realistic and bittersweet, emphasizing acceptance over a magical 'fix.'
A reflective 14-year-old who feels overshadowed by a sibling's needs or someone who is struggling with the 'survivor guilt' that often follows the death of a family member who struggled with mental illness.
Parents should be aware that the book deals candidly with mental health struggles. It may be helpful to discuss the challenges Lily faced as a caregiver, the feelings of guilt or resentment she experienced, and the impact of Jane's illness on their family dynamics. A parent might see their child withdrawing or expressing anger toward a deceased relative, or perhaps the child is struggling to 'perform' normalcy while grieving.
Younger readers (12) may focus on the spooky, ethereal mystery of Jane's ghost. Older readers (15-17) will likely resonate more with the themes of identity, the burden of caregiving, and the complexity of adolescent independence.
Griffin avoids the 'saintly victim' trope. Jane is portrayed as a complex, sometimes difficult person, which allows the reader to feel the full spectrum of Lily's grief, including her frustration. ```
The story is told through dual perspectives: Jane, who has died, and Lily, her younger sister who survives her. As children, they shared a rich, imaginative world, but as they grew older, Jane's inability to distinguish fantasy from reality became a symptom of her deteriorating mental health. The narrative follows Lily as she attempts to build a life in 'real time,' while Jane watches from a purgatory-like state, unable to fully cross over or let go of the bond that defined them both.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review