
Reach for this book when your child is struggling with the burden of a promise they aren't sure they can keep or when they feel like an outsider longing for a deep connection. It is a lyrical, atmospheric fairy tale about Nuria, the only child left in a village after a magical mishap, and her new friend Catty, who uses a wheelchair and desperately wants to walk. The story explores the heavy weight of responsibility and the unintended consequences of our deepest desires. While the prose is sophisticated and poetic, the emotional core is deeply relatable for children ages 8 to 12. It masterfully navigates themes of guilt, loyalty, and the realization that helping someone else often requires more than just a quick fix or a magical wish. Parents will appreciate how it handles the complexities of disability and the ethics of 'fixing' others with nuance and grace.
Themes of isolation, being the 'only' child left, and the frustration of physical limitations.
The magical transformations and the atmosphere of the well can be eerie and unsettling.
The story explores the protagonist's initial desire to 'cure' a physical disability, which some readers may find troubling. However, the resolution focuses on internal acceptance and adaptation rather than a magical cure. It also touches on profound loneliness and the fear of abandonment. The approach is secular but feels like a timeless folk myth.
A thoughtful 10-year-old who enjoys 'dark' fairy tales like Coraline or The Goose Girl, particularly one who is highly empathetic and perhaps feels a sense of 'imposter syndrome' in their friendships.
Read the 'wish' scene (Chapter 10) to prepare for the body-swap element. Some readers may find the descriptions of being trapped in a different body disorienting or claustrophobic. A parent might notice their child becoming overly anxious about a commitment they made to a friend, or perhaps a child who is trying too hard to 'fix' a peer's problems instead of just being a friend.
Younger readers (8-9) will focus on the magic and the mystery of the well. Older readers (11-12) will pick up on the sophisticated metaphors regarding identity, the ethics of Nuria's choice, and the atmospheric, almost gothic writing style.
Unlike many magic-at-a-price stories, Billingsley uses a highly unique, rhythmic prose style that elevates the psychological stakes, making the magic feel visceral and personal rather than just a plot device. """
Nuria lives with her grandfather in a village where a magical well once whisked away all the children in response to a misinterpreted wish. When Catty Winter arrives, she is the first child Nuria has seen in years. Catty has a physical disability and convinces Nuria to use her once-in-a-lifetime wish to make her walk. The wish goes hauntingly wrong, resulting in a body-swap that forces Nuria to navigate life in Catty's body while uncovering the true nature of the well and the village's past.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review