
For a child who feels like a square peg in a round hole, or who worries their unique talents don't fit the traditional definition of 'smart', Ungifted is a perfect choice. This hilarious and heartfelt story follows Donovan Curtis, a prankster who accidentally gets sent to a school for super-geniuses. As he tries to hide his very average academic abilities, he discovers that his creativity, people skills, and loyalty are exactly what his new, brilliant friends need. The book explores themes of belonging, self-identity, and the idea that there are many ways to be gifted. It’s a wonderfully funny and reassuring read for middle schoolers that champions teamwork and finding your place among the most unexpected of friends.
A significant subplot involves Donovan's pregnant older sister, whose husband is a Marine deployed in Afghanistan. This is handled realistically as a source of background family stress and worry. The approach is secular and the resolution to this side-plot is hopeful and focused on family support.
This book is ideal for a middle-grade reader (10-13) who feels academically average or like they don't quite fit a specific mold. It’s perfect for kids with a great sense of humor who may not see their own creative or social strengths as 'gifts'. It would also resonate with academically gifted children who feel the pressure of their label and may feel isolated.
The subplot about the military deployment in Afghanistan is a minor point but could be sensitive for children with family in the service. A parent might want to be prepared to discuss it. Otherwise, the book can be read cold. The pranks are comically exaggerated, but a quick 'don't try this at home' chat might be useful. A parent might reach for this after their child expresses feelings of not being 'smart enough', compares themselves unfavorably to peers, or after a parent-teacher conference focuses more on a child's disruptive behavior than their potential.
Younger readers (9-10) will latch onto the humor, the robot-building, and the funny antics of Donovan and his friends. Older readers (11-13) will appreciate the more nuanced social commentary on gifted programs, the pressures of labeling, and the core message that everyone has something valuable to contribute.
Unlike many books that focus on a single protagonist's journey, Ungifted uses multiple points of view to give readers insight into both the 'ungifted' and 'gifted' kids' perspectives. Its unique strength lies in its humor and its heartfelt message that emotional and creative intelligence are just as important as academic brilliance, making it a validating story for a wide range of young readers. """
Donovan Curtis is a known prankster whose latest stunt, involving the destruction of the school gym, lands him in hot water. A clerical error by the superintendent, however, mistakenly places his name on the acceptance list for the Academy of Scholastic Distinction, a magnet school for the highly gifted. To escape punishment, Donovan leans into the mistake and attempts to blend in with his genius classmates. He joins the robotics team, where his impulsive creativity and social skills prove to be an unexpected asset, helping the socially awkward team bond and innovate. The story follows Donovan's journey as he befriends his new classmates, challenges their and his own notions of intelligence, and tries to keep his secret from being exposed.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review