
Reach for this book when your child is struggling with a one-sided social dynamic, such as trying to be kind to a peer who continues to be unkind in return. It is a perfect choice for navigating the frustration of unfair treatment and the realization that 'turning the other cheek' has its limits. James Stevenson uses a whimsical, comic-strip style to explore the holiday season through the eyes of Emma, a young witch who makes a New Year's resolution to be nice to the older, meaner witches, Dolores and Lavinia. The story beautifully validates a child's sense of justice. While Emma starts with a pure heart, the relentless bullying from the older witches leads to a clever and humorous retaliation. For children aged 5 to 8, this book serves as a fantastic conversation starter about boundaries, the reality that not everyone will be your friend, and how to maintain your spirit in the face of negativity. It is a lighthearted yet resonant take on social resilience.
Emma is subjected to various mean-spirited pranks and magical tricks by the older witches.
The book deals with bullying and social exclusion. The approach is metaphorical, using 'witchy' behavior as a stand-in for schoolyard mean-girl dynamics. The resolution is realistic rather than purely idealistic: Emma doesn't change the bullies' hearts, but she does stop their behavior by standing up for herself.
An elementary student who is 'too nice' and often finds themselves being taken advantage of by more dominant personalities. It is for the child who needs to see that standing up for yourself is not the same as being a bully.
Read this cold. The comic-strip layout makes it an engaging visual experience that doesn't require pre-explaining. A parent might choose this after hearing their child say, 'I tried to be nice to them like you said, but they were still mean to me.'
Younger children (5-6) will enjoy the slapstick humor and the magical mishaps. Older children (7-8) will more deeply resonate with the social injustice and the cleverness of Emma's eventual revenge.
Unlike many 'be kind' books that end with the bully apologizing, this book acknowledges that some people are just 'dreadful' and that self-protection and humor are valid responses.
Emma the witch decides her New Year's resolution is to be nice to Dolores and Lavinia, regardless of how they treat her. The older witches take full advantage of this, tricking her into doing chores and mocking her kindness. After a series of escalating mean-spirited pranks by the duo, Emma realizes that her resolution isn't working. She uses her wit (and a bit of magic) to give them a taste of their own medicine on New Year's Day, ending their reign of terror with a humorous twist.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review