
A parent would reach for this book when their teenager is struggling to reconcile the person they are at home with the person they feel they must be to succeed in the world. It is a nuanced contemporary romance that explores the heavy weight of parental expectations, particularly within Latino families, through the eyes of two teens from very different backgrounds who meet on a New York City subway. The story addresses themes of mental health, systemic prejudice, and the courage it takes to pursue a dream that differs from a parent's vision. Due to its mature handling of anxiety, racism, and romantic intimacy, it is best suited for readers aged 14 and up who are navigating their own paths toward independence.
Realistic depiction of a sibling's struggle with schizophrenia and family impact.
The book deals directly and realistically with mental health (schizophrenia). The book also depicts instances of racial bias, such as when Alex is unfairly stopped and questioned by police in his own neighborhood, and explores the economic disparities between Alex's family, who struggle to make ends meet, and Isa's privileged upbringing. The approach to mental illness is secular and grounded in the reality of family caretaking. The resolution is hopeful but realistic, acknowledging that love doesn't fix everything, but honesty provides a path forward.
A high schooler who feels like they are living a double life or anyone who loves a 'star-crossed lovers' story set in a gritty, realistic urban environment. It is perfect for the teen athlete or artist who feels the crushing weight of a parent's 'investment' in their talent.
Parents should be aware of scenes involving police profiling, as well as scenes where Isa experiences microaggressions related to her Cuban-American identity, such as classmates making assumptions about her family's immigration status and teachers mispronouncing her name despite repeated corrections. There are also depictions of a character experiencing a mental health crisis. There is also moderate romantic intimacy and some strong language. A parent might see their child withdrawing or showing signs of burnout from extracurricular activities like competitive sports or dance. They might hear their child express fear about 'letting the family down' or notice them hiding a relationship.
Younger teens (13-14) will likely focus on the romance and the 'forbidden' nature of the relationship. Older teens (16-18) will better appreciate the nuances of the socioeconomic divide and the complex ethics of choosing self over family.
Unlike many YA romances, this book gives equal weight to both perspectives and uses the NYC subway as a powerful metaphor for the 'in-between' spaces where cultural and class identities collide. ```
Alex is a talented Dominican baseball player from a working-class neighborhood whose father is pushing him toward the MLB. Isa is a Cuban-American ballerina from a wealthy family, struggling with the pressure of being the 'perfect' daughter while her brother deals with severe mental illness. After a chance meeting on the train, the two begin a secret relationship that forces them to confront their prejudices, family loyalties, and their own futures.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review