
Reach for this book when your child feels overshadowed by a sibling's success or weighed down by the 'troublemaker' label. It is an ideal choice for the student who feels like they aren't the 'natural' talent in the room and fears they are destined for failure. Set in an alternate magical American frontier, the story follows Eff, a thirteenth child believed to be cursed with bad luck, while her twin brother is hailed as a magical prodigy. As her family moves to the edge of the dangerous Great Barrier, Eff must navigate her anxiety and the heavy burden of superstition to discover her own unique power. This middle-grade fantasy uses a 'weird west' setting to explore deep psychological themes of self-stigma and the self-fulfilling prophecy of being 'bad.' It is appropriate for ages 10 to 14, offering a slow-burning, thoughtful narrative that prioritizes emotional growth over fast-paced action. Parents will appreciate how it validates the quiet, observant child who finds strength in persistence rather than innate brilliance.
Significant emotional weight regarding being unwanted or 'cursed' by family members.
Occasional encounters with dangerous magical wildlife and the mystery of the Great Barrier.
The book deals heavily with systemic prejudice and psychological bullying (from family members). This is handled metaphorically through the 'thirteenth child' superstition. It is secular in nature, though it mirrors the rigidity of certain social or religious taboos. The resolution is realistic and hopeful, focusing on self-acceptance.
A 12-year-old who feels like the 'black sheep' of the family or a student who suffers from high anxiety about performance and perfectionism.
Read the scenes involving Aunt Charity (early chapters) to understand the level of emotional verbal abuse Eff endures, which may require discussion about how words can shape our self-image. A parent hears their child say, 'I'm just the bad kid,' or notices their child withdrawing because they feel they can't compete with a high-achieving sibling or peer.
Younger readers will focus on the 'cool' magical creatures like the mammoths and dragons. Older readers will resonate with the heavy themes of identity, the fear of puberty (the 'change'), and the pressure of social expectations.
Unlike many fantasy novels where the 'chosen one' has flashly powers, Wrede focuses on the 'unchosen' one. It’s a slow-burn, domestic fantasy that treats magic with the mundane detail of a science or a craft.
Eff is born a thirteenth child in an alternate 19th-century America where magic is a science. While her twin brother Lan is a 'seventh son of a seventh son' destined for greatness, Eff is shunned by her extended family as a source of bad luck. The family moves to the frontier (the North Plains) where her father helps manage the magical barrier protecting settlers from prehistoric, magical beasts. The story follows Eff from childhood to adolescence as she learns that magic isn't just about raw power, but about the intent and character of the person wielding it.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review