
A parent would reach for this book when their teenager is navigating the fallout of their first major heartbreak or struggling to find a sense of belonging within a specific community. It is an ideal choice for teens who feel like they have to hide parts of their true selves to fit in or stay safe, as the protagonist must keep her elemental powers secret from the non-magical world. The story follows Hannah, a witch in modern-day Salem, as she balances the typical stresses of high school, a new crush, and an ex-girlfriend with the high stakes of a magical mystery. It explores deep themes of trust, self-identity, and the courage required to stand up for one's community during a crisis. While the setting is fantastical, the emotional core is grounded in the realistic experience of being a queer teenager. The book deals with the complexities of lingering feelings for an ex and the vulnerability of starting something new with a stranger. Because of the inclusion of blood rituals and some suspenseful, darker moments, it is most appropriate for readers aged 14 and up. Parents might choose this book to help their teen process moving on from a relationship or to spark conversations about personal integrity and the weight of secrets.
Characters face physical danger from an unknown magical assailant.
Queer romance featuring kissing and emotional intensity regarding an ex-partner.
Includes blood rituals, dark magic, and a suspenseful 'whodunit' atmosphere.
Some magical combat and mentions of injuries sustained during rituals.
This book includes depictions of ritualistic magic involving blood, animal sacrifice (a dead cat is discovered), physical violence, kidnapping, and moments of intense peril. There are themes of stalking and betrayal within close relationships.
A 15-year-old who loves urban fantasy and is currently navigating the messy aftermath of their first serious relationship. It is perfect for a reader who feels they have to hide a significant part of themselves from the world and seeks a story where being queer is an established fact of life rather than the central conflict.
This book can generally be read cold, but parents may want to preview the scenes involving the discovery of blood rituals and the animal casualty if their teen is particularly sensitive to animal harm. A parent hears their teenager say, "I feel like I'm the only person who can't just be myself around here," or notices their child struggling to move on from a toxic friendship or breakup.
Younger teens (14) will likely focus on the excitement of the elemental magic and the suspense of the mystery. Older readers (17-18) will better appreciate the nuanced depiction of the post-breakup "friendship" and the social pressures of keeping secrets within a tight-knit community.
Unlike many YA fantasies where the queer identity is the source of the trauma, this book treats Hannah's sexuality as a baseline reality. The conflict is entirely driven by external magical threats and internal emotional growth, making it a refreshing example of queer joy and normalcy within a high-stakes genre.
Hannah is an Elemental Witch living in modern day Salem, Massachusetts, where magic must be kept hidden from non-magical people (Regs). While dealing with a painful breakup from her fellow witch ex-girlfriend, Veronica, and a budding romance with a new girl named Morgan, Hannah discovers evidence of a Blood Witch performing dangerous rituals. As the attacks escalate from property damage to life-threatening violence, Hannah must navigate complex social dynamics and magical politics to protect her community.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review