
A parent would reach for this book when their middle schooler is navigating the confusing, often guilt-ridden territory of a first crush, especially when those feelings conflict with loyalty to a friend. The story follows Polly Nelson as she grapples with an inconvenient attraction to her best friend's boyfriend, Ollie, while trying to move on with a new, seemingly perfect interest named Sam. It provides a safe space for young teens to explore the difference between surface-level attraction and genuine connection. This is a gentle, age-appropriate romance that captures the high-stakes emotions of Heartside High without crossing into mature content. You might choose this book to help your child normalize the 'messiness' of feelings. It emphasizes that having a crush isn't a choice, but how we act on those feelings defines our integrity. It is an ideal bridge for readers moving from childhood stories into more social, relationship-driven fiction.
Feelings of guilt and the fear of losing a best friend over a crush.
The book deals primarily with social and romantic ethics. The approach is direct and secular, focusing on the realistic consequences of keeping secrets in a small social circle. The resolution is hopeful and emphasizes personal growth and honest communication.
A 12 or 13-year-old girl who is starting to prioritize peer relationships and is beginning to experience the 'drama' of school crushes. She likely values her friendships deeply but is starting to feel the pull of individual romantic desires.
This is a very safe, 'clean' middle grade romance. No specific scenes require previewing, but parents should be ready to discuss the difference between an 'infatuation' and a 'relationship.' A parent might notice their child becoming more secretive about their phone, acting 'hot and cold' with a long-term best friend, or expressing anxiety about 'liking' someone they shouldn't.
Younger readers (11) will focus on the 'will-they-won't-they' excitement of the romance. Older readers (14) will likely identify more with the nuance of the 'friendship vs. crush' dilemma and the pressure to maintain a certain social image.
Unlike many YA romances that lean into melodrama, this book keeps the stakes grounded in the emotional reality of middle schoolers. It validates the intensity of these early feelings without making them feel tawdry.
Polly Nelson lives in the seaside town of Heartside Bay. While her best friend is dating the popular, athletic Ollie Wright, Polly finds herself developing an unwanted crush on him. To distract herself and remain a loyal friend, she begins dating Sam, who is intellectually compatible and kind. The story focuses on Polly's internal struggle to manage her guilt, her evolving feelings for both boys, and the social dynamics of her tight-knit friend group.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review