
Reach for this book when your child starts noticing the flaws in the adults they admire, or when they feel the pressure of being compared to someone else. This sophisticated mystery follows twelve year old Emily as she navigates a vacation shadowed by her father's suspicious behavior and a strange resemblance to a long dead girl in a famous painting. It is an ideal choice for middle schoolers grappling with the blurry line between appearance and reality. Through Emily's journey, the story explores heavy themes of family loyalty, the shame of parental dishonesty, and the courage it takes to claim one's own identity. It offers a safe space to discuss how we can love people even when we do not trust their choices.
Themes of a deceased child and the grief of those left behind.
The book deals with parental neglect and moral ambiguity. The father's unethical behavior is handled realistically and secularly. While the resolution is hopeful in terms of Emily's growth, the father's situation remains somewhat precarious, reflecting a realistic look at life with a 'ne'er-do-well' parent.
A thoughtful 11 year old who feels they are the 'adult' in the room with their parents, or a child who loves art history and atmospheric, gothic-leaning mysteries.
Read cold, but be prepared to discuss the ethics of art forgery and why Emily feels she must lie to protect her dad. A parent might see their child withdrawing or becoming overly protective of family secrets, or perhaps a child expressing frustration that they are always compared to a sibling or relative.
Younger readers will focus on the 'ghostly' mystery and the thrill of the secret game. Older readers will resonate with the complex social dynamics and the internal struggle of a girl trying to define herself apart from her father's shadow.
Unlike many mysteries that focus solely on the 'who-dunit,' this book is a deeply internal character study about the performance of identity and the burden of artistic temperament.
Emily is on holiday with her father, a talented but unsuccessful artist who often skirts the edge of legality. When she encounters Mallon, the heir to a grand estate, he is shocked by her resemblance to Sylvia, a girl depicted in a Renoir painting who died young. Emily soon finds herself playing the 'Sylvia Game' to please Mallon, while simultaneously suspecting her father is involved in a scheme to forge the very same painting. The mystery deepens as she befriends a local boy, Kevin, and tries to protect her father from his own worst impulses.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review