
Reach for this book when your child is grappling with the ache of wanting to belong or is expressing deep, quiet longings that seem out of reach. It is a soul-soothing choice for children navigating foster care, adoption, or simply the universal childhood fear of being left behind during the holidays. The story follows three parallel wishes: Ivy, an orphan searching for a grandmother; Holly, a Christmas doll wishing for a child; and Mrs. Jones, a woman with an empty house wishing for a daughter. This is a gentle, sophisticated tale that validates the weight of loneliness while offering a radiant, hopeful resolution. Godden's prose is elegant and timeless, making it an ideal choice for parents who want to nurture empathy and emotional resilience in their children. It is particularly powerful for children ages 5 to 10 who appreciate a story that takes their feelings seriously without being overly sentimental.
Themes of being unwanted and the loneliness of an orphanage.
The book deals with orphanhood and abandonment directly but within a traditional, almost folkloric framework. The tone is secular but carries a sense of 'fate' or 'magic' in the wishing. The resolution is deeply hopeful and realistic within its own world, providing a sense of security and permanent belonging.
An introspective 7-year-old who feels things deeply, perhaps a child who has recently experienced a move or a change in family structure and needs to believe that there is a place specifically reserved for them.
Read this cold; the surprise of the happy ending is part of the magic. However, be prepared to discuss what an 'orphanage' is, as the concept may be foreign to modern children. A parent might notice their child clinging to a specific toy for comfort or asking 'what happens to kids who don't have moms?' after seeing a sad news story or movie.
Younger children (5-6) focus on the 'toy coming to life' element and the holiday magic. Older children (8-10) will pick up on the poignant social commentary and the bravery Ivy shows in her self-reliance.
Unlike many holiday books that focus on Santa or spectacle, this is a masterclass in the 'theology of wishing.' It treats a child's internal desire as a powerful, world-shaping force.
The narrative follows Ivy, an orphan sent to a grim country home for Christmas who runs away to find a 'grandmother' she has only imagined. Simultaneously, Holly, a beautiful doll in a toyshop window, desperately wants to be owned by a child. Their paths converge through a series of coincidences and the quiet intervention of Mrs. Jones, a woman who finds herself preparing for a child she doesn't yet have.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review