
Reach for this book when your child begins asking complex questions about the blurred lines between right and wrong, or when they are ready to explore the emotional weight of history through a lens of compassion. Set in France during the Great War, the story follows two young sisters who discover a blind English soldier hiding in the woods. To thank them for their help and food, he shares a series of fables centered on a small silver donkey, each exploring themes of loyalty, sacrifice, and the quiet dignity of all living things. It is a sophisticated yet gentle exploration of integrity and the human cost of conflict. Parents will appreciate the way it models empathy for those who are suffering from unseen wounds, like post-traumatic stress, while maintaining a sense of wonder through the nested storytelling. It is an ideal choice for children aged 9 to 12 who are transitioning into more nuanced historical fiction.
The threat of the soldier being caught by authorities creates a sense of tension.
Themes of grief, war trauma, and a story involving a very ill child.
The book addresses war, desertion, and PTSD (psychological blindness). While the Nativity story is included, it is presented more as a beautiful legend than a religious lesson. The reality of illness and the threat of execution for desertion are present but handled with a gentle, fable-like quality.
A thoughtful 10-year-old who enjoys 'The Little Prince' or 'Charlotte's Web' and is beginning to realize that adults don't always have the answers, or a child who finds comfort in animals and folklore.
The soldier's blindness is psychosomatic, meaning it's caused by trauma rather than physical injury. This concept may require explanation for some children. Also, the concept of a 'deserter' and why he would be in trouble with his own side is a key conversation point. A child asking, 'Is it ever okay to break the rules to help someone?' or showing interest in the reality of soldiers beyond just 'heroes and villains.'
Younger readers will focus on the magic of the silver donkey and the bravery of the girls. Older readers (11+) will grasp the moral ambiguity of the soldier's choice to leave the front and the gravity of his trauma.
Hartnett uses a 'Russian Doll' narrative structure where the folk tales mirror the real-world stakes, elevating a standard historical drama into a timeless meditation on character. """
In 1914, sisters Marcelle and Coco find a British deserter named Lieutenant Shepard hiding in the French countryside. He is suffering from 'shell shock' and psychological blindness. The children decide to help him return to England. To pass the time and share his values, Shepard tells them four stories about donkeys: one about the Nativity, one about a brave donkey in WWI, one about a traveler, and one about his own brother, John. These stories serve as a moral compass for the children as they navigate the risk of harboring a soldier.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review