
Reach for this book when your teenager is struggling with the weight of a mistake or feels trapped by the person everyone thinks they should be. It is an ideal choice for the teen who is navigating social hierarchies, peer pressure, or the quiet guilt that comes from escaping consequences while others suffer. The story follows Paige, a popular high schooler whose life unravels after a drunk-driving accident she walked away from. While her community wants to pretend nothing happened, Paige is forced to confront the shallow nature of her status and find her own voice through a creative writing class. It is a realistic, nuanced exploration of integrity and the difficult choice between social comfort and personal truth. The book is best suited for older teens (14+) due to its honest depiction of high school drinking culture and complex social dynamics.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewExplores the ethics of privilege and failing to take responsibility for one's actions.
Themes of guilt, social isolation, and the trauma of a near-fatal accident.
Frequent depictions of underage drinking and the consequences of drunk driving.
The book deals directly and realistically with underage drinking, drunk driving, and the resulting trauma. The approach is secular and psychological, focusing on internal accountability. The resolution is realistic and bittersweet: Paige finds integrity but loses her previous social standing.
A high school student who feels like a 'perfectionist' or is feeling the suffocating pressure of a specific social label. It is perfect for the teen who has made a mistake and is struggling with how to make amends when the world tells them to just move on.
Parents should be aware of the frank depictions of high school parties and the physical/emotional aftermath of the car crash. Read the creative writing assignments (the 'Iowa' poems) to see how the protagonist processes her trauma. A parent might see their teen becoming withdrawn after a social fallout, or perhaps they have discovered their child has been involved in 'party culture' and want to discuss the ethics of entitlement.
Younger teens (14) will focus on the friendship drama and the 'mean girl' dynamics. Older teens (17-18) will likely connect more with the themes of systemic privilege and the terrifying transition out of high school.
Unlike many YA novels that focus on the 'victim' of an accident, this book focuses on the 'privileged survivor' and the moral weight of unearned immunity. It is a sharp critique of how communities protect 'their own' at the expense of the truth.
Paige Sheridan is high school royalty in a small Iowa town. Following a summer car accident involving underage drinking, Paige returns for her senior year feeling disconnected from her elite friend group and her distance-running identity. While her parents and peers want to brush the incident under the rug because of her status, Paige's guilt grows. Through a transformative creative writing class and new, unlikely friendships, she begins to dismantle her 'princess' persona to find an authentic self, eventually deciding to speak the truth about the accident regardless of the social cost.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.