
A parent might reach for this book when their teenager is trapped in a cycle of self-blame following a loss or a serious mistake. It is an ideal choice for a child who feels isolated by guilt and is searching for a way to say goodbye to someone they lost unexpectedly. The story follows seventeen-year-old Catherine, who is grieving a friend killed in a car accident she feels responsible for. While visiting her grandmother, she is targeted by a mysterious, supernatural entity claiming to be a medium who can bridge the gap between life and death. This atmospheric mystery explores the heavy burden of shame and the dangerous allure of seeking closure in places that seem too good to be true. It is a haunting yet grounded look at the vulnerability of grief, perfect for middle and high school readers who appreciate a spooky, psychological edge to their realistic fiction.
The protagonist is targeted and manipulated by a malevolent spirit.
Heavy focus on survivor's guilt and the tragic death of a teenage friend.
Atmospheric ghost story elements and a tense, supernatural confrontation at the climax.
The book deals directly with survivor's guilt and accidental death. The approach is realistic regarding the psychology of grief, though the antagonist is supernatural. It features a religious setting (a church) but the resolution is more about personal strength and discernment than specific dogma. The ending is hopeful as Catherine learns to carry her memory without the crushing weight of shame.
A teenager who enjoys gothic mysteries or ghost stories but is currently navigating a personal 'ghost' of their own, such as a deep regret or the loss of a peer.
Parents should be aware of the scene where the ghost attempts to 'claim' Catherine, which is intense and involves peril. The book can be read cold but offers great opportunities to discuss predatory behavior. A parent might notice their teen becoming withdrawn, obsessing over 'what if' scenarios regarding a past mistake, or looking for escapism in dark or questionable online communities or friendships.
Younger teens (12-13) will likely focus on the spooky, supernatural threat of the ghost. Older teens will resonate more with the nuanced portrayal of guilt and the danger of letting grief define one's identity.
Eve Bunting masterfully blends the 'creepy stranger' trope with a profound study of grief, making the supernatural element a metaphor for how guilt can consume us if we don't find healthy ways to let go.
Catherine is spending the holidays with her grandmother in a small California town, haunted by the memory of Hallie, her best friend who died in a car crash. When a charming stranger named Noah approaches her at a local church, he claims he can facilitate a meeting with Hallie's spirit. However, Noah is actually a 'Presence,' a ghost from the late 1800s who lures grieving girls into his trap to keep him company for eternity.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review