
Reach for this book when your child is asking about the gray areas of history or feeling the weight of being an outsider. It is a perfect companion for the middle grade reader who is noticing that the world is not always fair and that adults do not always have the answers. Set in 1941 Maine, the story follows Gusta, a girl sent to live in a grandmother's orphanage while her labor-activist father is in hiding. It beautifully weaves together themes of financial hardship, the sting of prejudice against immigrants, and the healing power of music and family secrets. Parents will appreciate the way it introduces complex historical tensions like alien registration and labor rights through the eyes of a resilient, nearsighted protagonist who is just trying to find her place in a divided town. It is a sophisticated but accessible historical novel that validates the feeling of being different while offering a hopeful path toward belonging.
Themes of family separation, poverty, and the stress of a parent in hiding.
The book depicts scenes of labor strikes with potential for physical injury, instances of xenophobia directed at Gusta and her family, and the anxiety surrounding potential deportation proceedings. While there is economic hardship and physical injury, the resolution is realistic and communal rather than magically perfect.
A thoughtful 10-year-old who feels like they don't quite fit in or who has a unique perspective on the world.
It is helpful to provide brief context on the labor movement and the pre-WWII atmosphere regarding foreign-born residents (the Alien Registration Act). A parent might see their child being excluded from a group or hear their child questioning why some people are treated poorly because of where they were born.
Younger readers will focus on the mystery of the Wish and the dynamics of the orphanage band. Older readers will grasp the political subtext of the labor unions and the irony of small-town prejudice during a time of supposed national unity. DIIFERENTIATOR: Unlike many WWII books that focus on the front lines, this highlights the domestic tensions of labor rights and the treatment of immigrants within the U.S., using a French horn as a powerful metaphor for harmony.
In 1941, Gusta is sent from New York to Springdale, Maine, to live in her grandmother's orphanage. Her father is a fugitive labor organizer, and her mother is struggling. Gusta brings her French horn and a heart full of her mother's stories about a magical Wish coin hidden by her grandfather. As she navigates a school where she is bullied because she's the new kid from New York and a family facing medical debt, Gusta forms a band with the orphans and uncovers a secret that could change the town's perception of patriotism and loyalty.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review