
Reach for this book when your child is starting to ask complex questions about where they come from, or when they feel like an outsider looking for a place to belong. It is a lyrical and slightly surreal story about two orphan girls, Naomi and Lizzie, whose lives in a small town are upended by the arrival of a mysterious boy and a series of strange events that link back to a grand estate in Ireland. The story weaves together themes of friendship, the ripples of past choices, and the magical way that people are interconnected across time and distance. Creech uses a whimsical, folk-tale style that makes the heavy topics of abandonment and family secrets feel safe and manageable for children ages 8 to 12. It is a beautiful choice for families exploring the concepts of foster care, adoption, or the idea that family is something we build as much as something we are born into.
A character falls from a tree and there is a legendary 'crooked bridge' that poses slight danger.
Themes of being an orphan and feelings of abandonment are central but handled gently.
The book deals with orphanhood and abandonment. The approach is metaphorical and stylized, feeling more like a contemporary fairy tale than a gritty realistic drama. It is secular in tone. The resolution is deeply hopeful, emphasizing that even when biological parents are absent, a child can be surrounded by a 'tangle' of people who love them.
A thoughtful 10-year-old who enjoys wordplay and mysteries, particularly one who might be grappling with their own family history or feeling like they don't quite fit the 'standard' family mold.
Read the chapters regarding Mrs. Kavanaugh's grudge. Her bitterness is a catalyst for the plot, and parents may want to discuss how adults sometimes hold onto anger for a long time. A child asking, 'Why didn't my first parents keep me?' or expressing a fear that they aren't 'special' because they don't know their full history.
Younger readers (8-9) will focus on the slapstick friendship of Naomi and Lizzie and the mystery of Finn. Older readers (11-12) will better grasp the parallel narrative in Ireland and the sophisticated themes of forgiveness and the interconnectedness of life.
Creech's unique, rhythmic prose and the dual-setting structure set this apart from typical middle-grade mysteries. It treats the search for identity as a magical adventure rather than a tragedy.
Naomi Deane and Lizzie Scatterding are best friends and orphans living in the quirky town of Blackbird Tree. Their world changes when Finn, a charming boy, literally drops from a tree into their lives. Simultaneously, a mysterious 'Dingle Dangle Man' begins lurking around town. Across the ocean in Ireland, an elderly woman named Mrs. Kavanaugh is plotting a way to right a past wrong involving a long-lost sister and a stolen inheritance. The two narratives converge as the girls discover that their identities are tied to a decades-old mystery involving a crooked bridge and a very 'Great Unexpected' inheritance.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review