
Reach for this book when your child is feeling the weight of being perfect or when they are struggling to navigate the messy reality of new friendships. It is a wonderful choice for children who are transitioning into independent reading but still crave a touch of whimsy and wonder in their everyday lives. The story follows twins James and Amanda who discover a girl with wings named Hilary in their bedroom. Unlike the ethereal angels of classic art, Hilary is loud, clumsy, and has very dirty feet. Through the lens of this magical guest, the book explores themes of empathy, the responsibility of caring for others, and the realization that everyone, even those we admire, has flaws. It is perfectly pitched for ages 8 to 12, offering a secular and humorous take on a traditionally religious figure. Parents will appreciate how the story subtly encourages children to look past first appearances and find the value in helping someone who doesn't quite fit the mold.
A character is injured with a broken wing and needs help.
The book uses the concept of an angel in a secular, folkloric way rather than a religious one. It touches on the idea of being an outsider and the physical vulnerability of being injured, handled with a hopeful and lighthearted tone.
An elementary schooler who loves 'secret guest' stories or a child who feels a bit like a misfit and would find comfort in a magical being who is just as unpolished as they are.
The book is safe to read cold. Parents might want to clarify that 'angel' here is used as a fantasy creature rather than a religious figure if that is a distinction they care about. A parent might see their children whispering, hiding food, or acting suspiciously 'helpful' to cover up a mess, reflecting the twins' behavior in the book.
Younger readers (7-8) will focus on the humor of Hilary's antics and the 'cool factor' of the wings. Older readers (10-12) will appreciate the irony of the subverted angel trope and the shifting dynamics between the skeptical and believing siblings.
Dyer avoids the saccharine tropes usually associated with angels. Hilary is refreshingly human: she is cranky, messy, and loud, making the 'magic' feel grounded and relatable.
James and Amanda find Hilary, a girl with wings and a broken arm, in their bedroom. James is a skeptic who believes only what he sees on the news, while Amanda is a dreamer. They decide to hide Hilary from their parents while her wing heals. The plot follows their attempts to keep her secret as Hilary's boisterous, non-angelic behavior (eating huge amounts of food and causing chaos) makes it nearly impossible. Eventually, the secret is out, and the family must decide how to help Hilary find her way home.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review