
Reach for this book when your teenager feels like an outsider in their own community or is struggling to balance their unique talents with social expectations. This supernatural historical mystery follows Evie O'Neill, a vivacious girl with a secret 'gift' for reading objects, as she is sent from her stifling Ohio hometown to the vibrant, dangerous world of 1920s New York City. Living with her eccentric uncle who runs a museum of the occult, she finds herself at the center of a chilling serial killer investigation involving an ancient, awakened evil. The story masterfully explores themes of identity, the weight of family grief, and the search for belonging within a diverse cast of characters. While it offers a glamorous look at the Jazz Age, it doesn't shy away from the darker realities of the era, including racism, poverty, and the looming shadows of the past. It is an excellent choice for mature teens who enjoy complex world-building, high-stakes mystery, and stories about finding one's chosen family.
Includes flirting, 'petting' (kissing/cuddling), and romantic tensions between characters.
Ritualistic murders and malevolent spirits are described with significant gore and tension.
Frequent depictions of 1920s speakeasy culture, including underage drinking and hip flasks.
Graphic ritualistic murders, occult horror, serial killing, descriptions of war trauma (WWI), scenes depicting racial discrimination in 1920s New York, poverty, and brief mentions of historical eugenics. There are scenes of physical violence and intense peril.
A mature teenager (14+) who feels like their personality is "too much" for their current environment and craves a story about finding a chosen family in a big city. It’s perfect for fans of historical fiction who don't want a sanitized version of the past.
Parents should be aware that this is a genuine horror novel; the murder scenes are vividly described. Parents may want to be prepared to discuss the historical context of racial discrimination and other forms of bigotry present in the 1920s, as depicted in the novel. A teen expressing a desire for more independence or feeling misunderstood by their local community, especially if they are interested in "spooky" or occult themes.
A 14-year-old will focus on the supernatural mystery and the social dynamics of the teens. An older teen or adult will better grasp the complex social commentary on American identity and the historical weight of the Great War.
It elevates the YA supernatural genre by grounding its magic in meticulously researched American history and folklore, refusing to shy away from the darker sociological aspects of the Jazz Age.
In 1926, vivacious flapper Evie O'Neill is exiled from Ohio to New York City after her psychometric ability to "read" secrets from objects causes a scandal. She stays with her uncle at his Museum of American Folklore, Superstition, and the Occult. When a ritualistic serial killer known as "Naughty John" begins terrorizing the city, Evie uses her gifts to assist the investigation. Along the way, she connects with other "Diviners" across the city, uncovering a larger conspiracy involving American history and ancient evil.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review