
A parent might reach for this book when their teenager is struggling with the pervasive feeling of being an outsider or when they seem overwhelmed by the mundane pressures of high school. While the setting is a school for witches and mutants, the narrative focuses entirely on the relatable, often awkward emotional reality of adolescence. It is a perfect choice for a child who feels that their inner life is too weird or too intense for the world around them. The book follows a diverse cast of students who grapple with unrequited crushes, body image, and the search for identity. Jillian Tamaki uses humor and surrealism to validate the teenage experience, showing that even if you can fly or cast spells, you still have to deal with social anxiety and existential dread. Because it deals with themes of sexuality and mild existential angst, it is best suited for readers aged 14 and up who appreciate a dry, indie-comic sensibility.
Absurdist humor sometimes treats dark or strange situations with nonchalance.
Includes depictions of unrequited queer pining and typical teenage dating dialogue.
Deals with loneliness, social isolation, and the fear of growing up.
This book includes mentions of existential dread and one character, the Everlasting Boy, who frequently contemplates and unsuccessfully attempts to end his immortal life in a stylized, philosophical manner. There are also brief depictions of mild substance use (smoking) and some dark humor regarding mortality.
A 15 or 16-year-old who feels like an outsider and enjoys deadpan humor. This is for the teen who finds traditional superhero stories too earnest and would rather read about a character worrying about their future or a girl pining for her best friend.
Parents may want to preview the "Everlasting Boy" strips, as they deal with the concept of immortality and the desire for rest. The book can generally be read cold by teenagers, but it may spark conversations about nihilism. A parent might notice their child withdrawing into their own world, expressing that "nothing matters," or displaying a sharp, cynical wit as a defense mechanism against the pressures of fitting in.
A 13-year-old might focus on the absurdist humor and the cool mutant powers. An older teen will connect more deeply with the subtext of social isolation, the complexity of closeted crushes, and the looming anxiety of adulthood.
Unlike most YA graphic novels that use magic as a metaphor for a grand destiny, Tamaki uses magic to highlight how mundane life remains even when you are extraordinary. It is uniquely honest about the "ugliness" of being a teenager. """
Set in a boarding school for mutants and magic-users, this collection of vignettes focuses on the banal, awkward, and existential reality of being a teenager. While students possess powers ranging from immortality to shapeshifting, the narrative prioritizes their internal lives: unrequited crushes, body image struggles, artistic pretension, and the search for meaning in a chaotic world.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review