
Reach for this book when your child is struggling with a classmate who seems to disagree with everything they say or do. It is a perfect choice for navigating the friction that occurs when two different personalities, or two different ways of seeing the world, collide in a shared space. The story follows Stella, a lover of logic and poetry, who finds herself in a heated disagreement with Horace Broom, a boy who insists that everything in her poem must be factually true. This gentle, humorous story explores the frustration of being misunderstood and the vulnerability of sharing one's creative work. DiCamillo expertly models how conflict can transition into connection through shared experience and a little bit of unexpected adventure. It is ideal for children aged 6 to 9 who are learning to balance their own creative impulses with the social realities of the classroom. You will appreciate how it validates a child's big feelings while offering a hopeful path toward reconciliation.
The book is entirely secular and grounded in realistic school life. It touches on the anxiety of being trapped in a dark, small space, but the approach is gentle and focused on the emotional connection between the children rather than the peril.
An elementary student who is highly imaginative but finds themselves frequently 'policed' by more literal-minded peers. It is also excellent for the child who is very rule-oriented and struggles when others don't follow the facts.
The book is safe to read cold. Parents may want to be ready to discuss why Horace feels the need to be so literal (it often comes from his own anxiety) to help the child build empathy for the 'difficult' peer. A parent might choose this after hearing their child complain about a 'know-it-all' classmate or after a teacher mentions the child is having trouble working in groups.
Six-year-olds will focus on the humor of the flying pig and the 'scary' closet. Eight and nine-year-olds will better grasp the nuance of the social conflict and the internal shift Stella makes when she decides to be kind to Horace.
Unlike many books about school conflict that rely on a 'bully' trope, this story treats both children with dignity. It shows that conflict often arises from different temperaments rather than malice.
Stella Endicott is excited to share a poem about a pig with wings, but her classmate Horace Broom insists that pigs cannot fly and therefore the poem is wrong. Their argument leads to a trip to the principal's office and an accidental lockout in a dark closet. While trapped, the two must move past their rigid viewpoints to find common ground and comfort in each other's company.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review