
Reach for this book when your teenager is grappling with the feeling of being an outsider or is navigating the isolating waters of intense grief. Janet Lunn's evocative novel follows fifteen year old Mary Urquhart as she leaves her Scottish Highland home for the rugged wilderness of Upper Canada in the 1800s. Guided by a psychic 'second sight' that her new community views with suspicion, Mary must face the devastating reality of a lost loved one while carving out an identity in a world that fears her unique gifts. It is a sophisticated exploration of resilience and the struggle to belong. Parents will find it an excellent bridge for discussing how we handle cultural misunderstandings and the importance of staying true to oneself even when faced with social rejection. While it touches on heavy themes like suicide and loneliness, the prose is lyrical and the emotional resolution is grounded and realistic for the 12 to 16 age range.
Historical survival elements including harsh winters and wilderness dangers.
Central plot involves the suicide of a loved one and deep mourning.
Atmospheric descriptions of psychic visions and 'ghostly' presence.
The book deals directly with death by suicide, which is handled with historical gravity and secular realism. The book depicts Mary being ostracized and accused of witchcraft due to her perceived mental instability and 'second sight,' reflecting the historical treatment of individuals deemed different. The resolution is realistic: Mary does not 'lose' her powers to fit in, but finds a way to coexist with her new reality.
A thoughtful 14 year old who feels 'different' from their peers or who is interested in the darker, more atmospheric side of history. It’s perfect for the quiet, observant teen who appreciates lyrical writing.
Parents should be aware of the suicide plot point early in the book. It is handled respectfully but may require a check-in regarding the child's emotional readiness for themes of self-harm and depression. A parent might notice their child withdrawing or expressing that 'no one understands them,' or perhaps the child is showing a burgeoning interest in historical folklore and ghost stories.
Younger readers (12) will focus on the survival elements and the 'ghostly' atmosphere. Older readers (15+) will better grasp the nuance of Mary's social isolation and the feminist undertones of a woman being feared for her intuition.
Unlike many pioneer stories that focus on the 'taming' of the land, this book focuses on the 'taming' of the internal landscape and the friction between Old World mysticism and New World pragmatism. """
Set in the 1815, Mary Urquhart travels from Scotland to Hawthorn Bay, Ontario, after hearing her cousin Duncan's psychic call for help. Upon arrival, she discovers Duncan has died by suicide. Isolated by her grief and her 'second sight' (which the local settlers perceive as witchcraft or mental instability), Mary must survive the physical hardships of pioneer life and the social sting of being an outcast.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review