
Reach for this book when your teen feels more at home in online communities than in the high school cafeteria. It is a sharp, funny, and deeply relatable look at the life of Scarlett Epstein, a cynical yet creative girl who processes her social frustrations by writing fanfiction about her classmates. While the book captures the sting of unrequited crushes and the loneliness of being the 'weird kid,' it also celebrates the unconventional friendships that can ground us. Parents should be aware of realistic teen language and sexual frankness, but the heart of the story is about finding the courage to be vulnerable in real life. It is an excellent choice for supporting a teen who is struggling to balance their digital identity with their physical reality.
Frank discussions of teenage sexuality and sexual desire.
Occasional references to drinking and parties.
The book includes references to alcohol consumption and sexual exploration typical of older YA fiction. There is a sub-plot involving the death of an elderly character toward the end of the novel.
A 15-year-old who feels like an outsider in their own school. This is for the student who finds more solace in fandom, coding, or creative writing than in school assemblies, and who might be using sarcasm as a shield against the fear of being disliked.
This book can be read cold, but parents should be aware that the dialogue is authentic to modern teen speech, including profanity and frank discussions about sex. The exploration of Ruth's past provides a beautiful, grounded perspective on queer history that offers a great conversational bridge. A parent might notice their teen becoming increasingly withdrawn or secretive about their online activity, or perhaps expressing intense frustration with the 'shallowness' of their peers.
Younger teens (13-14) will likely focus on the romantic drama and the humor of the fanfiction snippets. Older teens (16-18) will better appreciate the nuanced critique of social media performance and the bittersweet growth Scarlett undergoes as she reconciles with her parents' flaws.
Unlike many books that demonize the internet, this story treats online fandom as a legitimate and vital community while still challenging the protagonist to step outside of it. It uniquely balances razor-sharp wit with a genuinely touching intergenerational friendship.
Scarlett Epstein is a cynical, fanfiction-obsessed teenager whose social world revolves around a niche online community for a recently canceled TV show. When her crush, Gideon, starts dating the popular Ashley, Scarlett begins writing a scandalous fanfiction serial starring her real-life classmates. The narrative follows her navigation of high school hierarchy, a burgeoning friendship with her elderly lesbian neighbor Ruth, and the eventual fallout when her private digital writing clashes with her physical reality.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review