
A parent would reach for this book when their teenager feels like an isolated island in a sea of conformity or is struggling with the quiet barbs of small-town prejudice. It is an ideal choice for the student who finds solace in counter-culture, mystery, and a tight-knit circle of fellow outcasts rather than the mainstream school crowd. Montgomery Sole is a witty, sharp, and deeply relatable protagonist navigating the complexities of having two moms in a conservative town while exploring the line between coincidence and the supernatural. The story deals with bullying and social friction with a realistic, grounded perspective that validates the teen experience of being different. It is most appropriate for readers aged 12 and up who are beginning to define their own identities against the backdrop of community expectations. Parents will appreciate the book's nuanced portrayal of family loyalty and the way it honors the fierce, protective nature of teenage friendships.
Characters struggle with how to respond to those who hate them.
Atmospheric tension regarding the supernatural elements and a sense of being watched.
This book depicts instances of homophobic bullying and verbal harassment directed at the protagonist and her family. There are also themes of social ostracization and the emotional toll of community prejudice.
A 14-year-old who feels like they are constantly at odds with their environment, perhaps living in a community where their family structure or personal interests are treated as "other," and who needs to see that their weirdness is a superpower.
This book can be read cold by most teens. Parents may want to be aware of the scenes involving the "Eye of Know" to discuss the difference between wanting a magical solution to problems and the reality of dealing with social conflict. A parent hears their child describe a situation where a teacher or community figure made a dismissive or harmful comment about their family, or realizes their child is retreating into a shell to protect themselves from school-based harassment.
A 12-year-old will likely focus on the mystery elements and the "us vs. them" dynamic of the school hallway. A 16-year-old will better appreciate the nuanced critique of small-town politics and the internal emotional labor required to maintain one's identity in a hostile environment.
Tamaki avoids the "very special episode" trope by making Montgomery's two moms a stable, loving, and secondary background fact rather than the central problem. The unique blend of realistic social friction with a hint of the occult creates a singular, atmospheric voice.
Montgomery Sole is a high schooler in a small, conservative town who navigates life with her two moms and her two best friends, Thomas and Naoki. Together, they run the Mystery Club, exploring the supernatural and the unexplained. When a bigoted preacher arrives in town and Montgomery's social circle is targeted, she purchases a "Eye of Know" amulet online, hoping it possesses real power. The story follows her journey through bullying, social isolation, and the realization that the most potent magic is often found in human connection and resilience.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review