
Reach for this book when your child is grappling with the heavy weight of a secret mistake or the fear of getting in trouble at school. It is an ideal resource for children who struggle with the internal pressure of perfectionism or who have accidentally crossed a boundary and don't know how to fix it. The story follows first-grader Posey, who finds a shiny earring on the floor and hides it in her pocket, only to find that the guilt of keeping it grows heavier by the minute. Stephanie Greene masterfully captures the physical and emotional sensation of shame for the five to eight year old set. Through Posey's journey, parents can help their children understand that honesty is the best way to relieve the 'stomach aches' caused by secrets. This gentle chapter book models how to make a sincere apology and shows that adults, particularly teachers, can be sources of grace and understanding rather than just discipline.
Posey experiences significant emotional distress and guilt over her secret.
The book deals with the concept of 'stealing' by omission (finding and keeping). The approach is direct and secular, focusing on the internal moral compass of a child. The resolution is realistic and deeply hopeful, emphasizing restoration over punishment.
An early elementary student who is highly sensitive to rules and teacher approval. This is perfect for the child who feels 'naughty' even for small accidents and needs to see that one mistake does not make them a bad person.
This book can be read cold. It is helpful for parents to be ready to discuss the difference between 'finding' and 'keeping' before starting the middle chapters. A parent might see their child being unusually quiet, hiding an object, or showing physical signs of anxiety (like a tummy ache) after school without a clear medical cause.
A five-year-old will focus on the 'magic' of the treasure and the fear of the teacher being mad. A seven or eight-year-old will better internalize the nuance of the social-emotional conflict and the bravery required to admit a mistake.
Unlike many 'lesson' books, Posey is not a 'bad' kid doing a 'bad' thing. She is a relatable, 'good' kid who makes a common impulse-control mistake, making the message much more accessible and less preachy.
Posey finds a small, blue, heart-shaped earring in the hallway at school. Instead of turning it in, she pockets it, feeling the thrill of a new treasure. However, when she realizes the earring belongs to her beloved teacher, Miss Hunt, her excitement turns to dread. The story tracks Posey's internal struggle with guilt and her eventual decision to come clean and return the item.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review