
Reach for this book when your child is navigating the tricky social waters of a new school or feeling the pressure to change their personality to impress a crush. It speaks directly to the anxiety of not feeling 'enough' as you are. Pretending follows Sean, who feels pushed aside when his friend Kate becomes enamored with a sophisticated student intellectual. In a desperate attempt to win her back, Sean enlists a ghostwriter to craft deep poetry, creating a web of deception that eventually spirals out of control. It is an ideal choice for middle-grade readers (ages 8 to 12) who are beginning to explore romantic interests and the ethics of social performance. You would choose this book to help your child understand that authenticity is the only foundation for a lasting relationship and that lies, even well-intentioned ones, eventually come to light.
Focuses on middle school crushes and the desire for romantic attention.
The book handles social rejection and the ethics of ghostwriting (academic/creative dishonesty) in a secular, realistic manner. The resolution is realistic: it emphasizes the consequences of lying while offering a hopeful path toward genuine self-acceptance.
A 10-year-old who feels 'average' compared to high-achieving peers and needs to see that their true personality is more valuable than a curated image.
Read cold. No specific triggers, though parents might want to discuss the ethics of Hope writing for Sean and why Sean felt he couldn't use his own voice. A parent might notice their child exaggerating their interests or changing their vocabulary and style of dress just to fit in with a specific social clique.
Younger readers will enjoy the 'cringe comedy' of Sean trying to act smart. Older readers will resonate more deeply with the romantic rejection and the pressure to perform an identity.
Unlike many 'new kid' stories, this focuses specifically on the intellectual insecurity that comes with middle school and the unique dynamic of using a 'Cyrano de Bergerac' trope for a modern pre-teen audience.
The story centers on Sean, who finds himself 'left in the cold' by Kate, a girl he likes, when she becomes infatuated with a highbrow student intellectual. Desperate to regain her attention, Sean convinces his friend Hope to ghostwrite soulful, intellectual love poems for him to send to Kate. As Kate falls for the 'poetic' Sean, he must maintain a facade that becomes increasingly exhausting and dishonest, leading to an inevitable confrontation with the truth.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review