
Reach for this book when your middle schooler feels like they do not fit in or is struggling to navigate the complex social hierarchies of junior high. It is a perfect choice for the child who feels invisible and needs to see that confidence is often a choice rather than a personality trait. In this memoir, Maya Van Wagenen chronicles her real-life experiment of following a 1950s popularity guide for one school year. Beyond the humor of vintage fashion and girdles, the story explores deep themes of kindness, social courage, and the realization that everyone, even the popular kids, is fighting their own battles. It is highly appropriate for ages 10 to 14, providing a roadmap for self-acceptance through a lens of empathy rather than conformity. Parents will appreciate how it models resilience and the importance of looking past labels to find genuine connection.
Discussion of social isolation and the death of a classmate.
References to school bomb threats and the general tension of a rough school environment.
The book deals with real-world issues including school violence (bomb threats and lockdowns), poverty, and the pressures of living in a border town. The approach is direct and secular. The resolution is realistic: Maya doesn't become the 'queen bee,' but she finds a sense of peace and belonging that is deeply hopeful.
A thoughtful 11 to 13-year-old who feels like an outsider and is observant of the 'unwritten rules' of middle school. It is for the kid who wants to be brave but needs a gentle nudge to realize that being themselves is enough.
Parents should be aware of a few mentions of school lockdowns and the mention of a peer's death, which adds a layer of reality to the setting. If reading with a younger child, be prepared to discuss some of the outdated gender roles presented in the 1950s guide, such as the emphasis on girls being primarily concerned with attracting male attention. A parent might see their child sitting alone at lunch, or hear their child say, 'Nobody at school likes me' or 'I'm a geek.'
Younger readers will find the vintage fashion and 'old fashioned' rules funny. Older readers will resonate more with the internal struggle of social identity and the risk involved in social experimentation.
Unlike many 'how to be popular' books, this is a true story written by a teen as she lived it. It successfully bridges the gap between vintage charm and modern-day grit. """
Maya Van Wagenen, an eighth-grader in a Texas border town, decides to spend an entire school year following the advice in 'Betty Cornell's Teen-Age Popularity Guide' from 1951. Each month, Maya tackles a new chapter, ranging from diet and posture to fashion and social interaction. While the physical changes (like wearing a girdle to school) provide comedic moments, the heart of the story lies in Maya's decision to step out of her comfort zone and talk to people from every social clique.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review


