
A parent would reach for this book when their teenager is struggling with the pressure of comparison or feeling like they are living in someone else's shadow. It speaks to the universal adolescent desire to break free from expectations and find a unique sense of self. The story follows May, a girl in modern Florence who discovers a time portal and a doppelganger from the era of the Black Death. As May navigates a romance with a historical painter and a dangerous identity swap, the book explores deep themes of jealousy, trust, and the courage required to claim one's own life. While the historical plague setting adds a layer of intensity, the focus remains on the emotional resilience needed to confront one's own darker impulses. It is an excellent choice for mature middle schoolers and high schoolers who enjoy atmospheric mysteries with a touch of romance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewSweet, historically grounded romantic interest and longing.
Depictions of the Black Death and the resulting loss of life and community panic.
Atmospheric tension and the threat of being trapped in a plague-ridden past.
The book deals with identity and mortality directly. The plague is depicted with historical realism, showing illness and death. The approach to identity is psychological and metaphorical: the doppelganger represents the 'shadow self' or the person we fear we might become. The resolution is realistic and hard-won.
A 14-year-old girl who feels 'invisible' or overshadowed by peers and enjoys dark, atmospheric historical fiction like the works of Libba Bray.
Parents should be aware of the historical depictions of the plague, which include descriptions of illness and the fear of death. The romance is age-appropriate but intense. A parent might notice their teen expressing deep envy of others' lives on social media or feeling like they have to 'perform' a certain personality to fit in.
Younger teens (12-13) will focus on the 'twin' mystery and the portal fantasy. Older teens (15+) will better grasp the nuance of the identity theft and the psychological weight of choosing one's own path.
Unlike many time-travel romances, this book focuses heavily on the 'dark side' of the double. It uses the mirror motif to explore the danger of losing oneself in the desire to be someone else.
May is spending a summer in Florence, Italy, feeling disconnected and ordinary. She discovers a portal in a mirror that leads back to the 1300s, during the onset of the Black Death. There, she meets Giovanna, her literal double. While May is enchanted by the beauty of the Renaissance and a handsome painter named Marco, Giovanna is desperate to escape the looming plague. The two trade places, but May soon realizes Giovanna has no intention of switching back, forcing May to fight for her identity and her survival in a dying city.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.