
Reach for this book when your teenager is struggling to understand the presence of hate in the world or is processing a news event involving social injustice and prejudice. This is a collection of sixty-eight poems that reflect on the 1998 kidnapping and murder of Matthew Shepard, a gay college student. It explores the event from multiple perspectives, including the fence he was tied to and the stars above, to help readers process the gravity of hate crimes through a lens of empathy rather than just trauma. While the subject matter is undeniably heavy, Lesléa Newman uses the beauty of verse to create a safe space for reflection. It is an essential choice for parents looking to foster a deep sense of social justice and allyship in their high schoolers. By moving through the tragedy toward a call for a more compassionate future, the book helps teenagers find a constructive way to channel their anger and sadness into a commitment to kindness.
Themes of grief, loss, and community mourning are present throughout.
Description of the assault is handled through poetic imagery but remains impactful.
Explicit depictions of a violent hate crime, kidnapping, torture, and death. References to homophobic slurs and intense physical suffering.
A high school student who is deeply engaged in social justice work or who is struggling to process the reality of bigotry and violence in the news. It is for the empathetic reader who uses literature to make sense of societal failures.
Parents should be aware that the poems describing the physical violence are blunt and heartbreaking. It is recommended to read the author’s note and the final poems together to ensure the focus remains on the message of hope and change rather than just the trauma. A parent might reach for this when their teenager asks, "How could someone do this to another person?" or after the child expresses fear or anger following a report of a local or national hate crime.
Younger teens (14) will likely focus on the injustice and the emotional weight of the loss. Older teens (17-18) may engage more with the poetic forms and the historical context of how this event changed hate crime legislation.
Unlike standard biographies or true crime accounts, this book uses personification and shifting perspectives to give a voice to the silent witnesses of history, making a difficult topic accessible through the distance of lyrical poetry.
This verse novel explores the 1998 hate crime murder of Matthew Shepard through sixty-eight poems. Rather than a linear narrative of Matthew’s life, the poems use various perspectives, including the fence, the stars, and the bicycle rider who found him, to process the impact of the tragedy and the subsequent trial.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review