
Reach for this book when your child is first asking about why people get old or when a great-grandparent is becoming frail or has recently passed away. It provides a gentle, secular framework for understanding the natural cycle of life through the eyes of four-year-old Tommy, who shares a special bond with his grandmother (Nana Downstairs) and his frail great-grandmother (Nana Upstairs). This autobiographical story by Tomie dePaola captures the warmth of multigenerational love while honestly addressing the reality of aging and the transition of death. It is perfectly suited for children aged 4 to 8, offering a safe space to discuss the physical changes that come with old age and the lasting comfort of memory. Parents will appreciate how it validates a child's questions and feelings without being overly clinical or overly sentimental.
Deals with the grief of losing beloved family members.
The book handles death directly but gently. It is secular in nature, focusing on the metaphor of a falling star as a "kiss" from those who have passed. The approach to aging is realistic, showing physical frailty and the use of restraints for safety, which is handled with dignity.
A preschooler or early elementary student who is noticing a grandparent becoming more tired or sick, or a child who has just attended their first funeral and needs to see that life continues while love remains.
Parents should be prepared for the scene where Nana Upstairs is tied into her chair (for safety) and the moment where Tommy sees her empty bed. It is best to read this with the child to answer questions about what happens to the body. A parent might notice their child asking, "Why does Nana have to stay in bed?" or "Where did she go?" after a death, or perhaps the child is frightened by the physical changes they see in an elderly relative.
Younger children (4-5) will focus on the fun rituals Tommy shares with his Nanas. Older children (7-8) will more deeply process the concept of the "falling star" and the passage of time as Tommy grows up.
Unlike many books that use animals as proxies for grief, this is a semi-autobiographical human story. Its unique strength lies in depicting the specific, slightly messy, and very beautiful reality of caring for the very old.
Tommy visits his grandmother and great-grandmother every Sunday. Nana Downstairs is active in the kitchen, while ninety-four-year-old Nana Upstairs stays in bed. Tommy loves them both, even getting tied into a chair next to Nana Upstairs so they can talk safely. Eventually, Nana Upstairs passes away, followed years later by Nana Downstairs. The book concludes with Tommy as an adult, seeing falling stars and remembering them both.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review