
A parent would reach for this book when their child is beginning to question the 'rules' of gender or feels restricted by societal expectations of how they should dress, act, or earn a living. It is a powerful choice for a middle schooler who values authenticity and is looking for historical proof that people have always pushed against the boundaries of identity to find freedom and security. Based on the true story of Jennie Hodgers, the narrative follows an Irish immigrant who adopts the persona of Albert Cashier to secure better pay and eventually serves as a Union soldier in the Civil War. While the setting is historical, the emotional core focuses on resilience, the courage to live on one's own terms, and the quiet strength found in self-definition. It offers a grounded, realistic look at the sacrifices and rewards of choosing an unconventional path.
Historical depictions of Civil War battles and injuries.
War, physical violence, injury, and death in the context of historical combat. There are depictions of the harsh realities of the Civil War, including the loss of friends and the physical toll of military service.
A 12-year-old reader interested in stories of courage, resilience, and historical figures who challenged societal norms. It is perfect for the student who loves military history but doesn't see themselves represented in traditional soldier narratives.
Parents should be prepared to discuss the historical context of the Civil War and the limited rights of women in the 19th century. Parents should be prepared to discuss the systemic injustices of the 19th century that limited opportunities for women and forced some individuals to conceal their true identities in order to survive and thrive. The combat scenes are realistic for the middle-grade level but may require some debriefing regarding the loss of secondary characters. A child expresses frustration about societal expectations or asks about historical figures who faced similar challenges.
A 10-year-old will likely focus on the adventure and the "disguise" element of the plot. A 14-year-old will more deeply grasp the internal necessity of Albert's choice and the systemic injustice that made such a life-long commitment to a secret identity necessary for survival.
Unlike many stories of women who cross-dressed for war only to return to traditional lives, this book honors the real Albert Cashier, who lived as a man for the remainder of his life, offering a rare glimpse into the life of a transgender man in the 19th century. """
Based on the true history of Jennie Hodgers, this novel follows an Irish immigrant who arrives in America and quickly realizes that life as a woman is synonymous with poverty and restriction. To secure a living wage and personal freedom, she adopts the identity of Albert Cashier. As Albert, she enlists in the 95th Illinois Infantry and fights as a Union soldier during the American Civil War, maintaining this identity through the hardships of camp life and the terrors of the battlefield.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review