
Reach for this book when your middle schooler is navigating the comedy of errors that often accompanies a first crush or the sudden, intense pressure to be cool. It is the perfect choice for a child who feels like they are the only one making embarrassing mistakes or overthinking social interactions. The story follows three very different eighth-grade boys: Sam, Duke, and Chollie: who all fall for the same girl, Miranda Mullaly, leading to a series of hilarious misunderstandings and competitive antics. While the plot is driven by a shared crush, the heart of the book explores how preteens project their own desires onto others and the importance of seeing peers as real people rather than prizes. It addresses jealousy, the struggle for self-confidence, and the messy reality of middle school friendships with a light, humorous touch. Parents will appreciate how it normalizes the awkwardness of early adolescence without being heavy-handed, making it a safe and relatable read for the 10 to 14 age group.
Focuses on middle school crushes and unrequited feelings, very innocent.
The book deals with typical middle school social dynamics. There is some minor peer pressure and social exclusion, but the approach is secular and highly comedic. The resolution is realistic, as the boys eventually have to face the fact that Miranda is her own person with her own agency.
An 11 or 12-year-old boy who is starting to notice classmates but feels completely out of his element. It is especially great for kids who enjoy humor-driven realistic fiction like 'Diary of a Wimpy Kid' but are ready for something with slightly more mature social themes.
This is a safe read-cold book. Parents might want to discuss the concept of 'misreading signals' afterward, as much of the humor comes from the boys' delusional confidence. A parent might see their child becoming suddenly self-conscious, acting 'extra' to impress someone, or perhaps getting into petty arguments with friends over a shared interest or crush.
Younger readers (10-11) will find the physical comedy and 'fails' hilarious. Older readers (13-14) will likely wince with recognition at the social anxiety and the specific brand of middle school embarrassment.
Unlike many 'first crush' books told from a single perspective, Gerhardt’s use of three distinct male protagonists provides a panoramic and funny look at how different personalities handle the same social pressure.
The narrative is split between three eighth-grade boys: Sam (the rule-follower), Duke (the intense athlete), and Chollie (the easygoing schemer). All three become infatuated with Miranda Mullaly, often interpreting her neutral or even negative interactions as signs of secret love. As they compete for her attention through ill-conceived gestures and biology class mishaps, their paths cross in ways that highlight their individual insecurities and the absurdity of their assumptions.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review