
Reach for this book when your child starts noticing that the Tooth Fairy's 'exchange rate' varies between households, or when you see the first sparks of a crafty but ethically questionable business mind. It is an ideal choice for navigating the social comparisons that crop up in the classroom once the first teeth start falling out. In this humorous school story, Martin realizes he is getting more money for his teeth than his classmates. He decides to capitalize on this by acting as a middleman, charging a fee to put his friends' teeth under his own pillow. The story explores the fallout of this 'tooth-brokering' scheme, touching on themes of fairness, honesty, and the realization that some secrets are meant to be kept. It is a lighthearted way to discuss why different families have different rules and the importance of personal integrity over a quick profit.
The book approaches the Tooth Fairy myth in a secular, matter-of-fact way. While it doesn't explicitly 'break the magic' for all children, it deals heavily with the transactional nature of the myth. The resolution is realistic and grounded in parental correction.
An entrepreneurial first or second grader who is highly motivated by rewards or is beginning to compare their 'stuff' and 'allowance' to what their friends have at school.
Parents should be aware that the book acknowledges the Tooth Fairy as a parental role by the end. If you are strictly maintaining the 'magic' without any meta-commentary, pre-read to ensure it fits your household's narrative. A parent might reach for this after hearing their child say, 'But Joey got five dollars for his tooth and I only got a quarters!' or after catching their child in a 'victimless' white lie involving money.
4-to-5-year-olds will focus on the humor of the missing teeth and the 'gross' factor. 7-to-8-year-olds will better grasp the economic 'hustle' and the ethical dilemma of Martin's commission-based business.
Most tooth books focus on the fear of the dentist or the excitement of the loss; this is unique for focusing on the social-economic hierarchy of the playground and the ethics of arbitrage.
Martin discovers he receives more money per tooth than his peers. He recruits classmates to let him 'rent' their lost teeth, promising them a cut of his higher Tooth Fairy payout while keeping a commission for himself. The plan collapses when the Tooth Fairy (and his parents) become wise to the sudden influx of teeth, leading to a lesson on honesty and the purpose of the tradition.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review



















