
Reach for this book when your teenager is struggling with the fallout of a broken friendship or is beginning to ask deep, existential questions about faith and the afterlife. It serves as a compassionate bridge for teens navigating the 'silent treatment' or the guilt that comes from things left unsaid. The story follows two former best friends, Hannah and Emory, who are forced back into each other's orbits after a life-altering accident involving Emory's boyfriend. Through their dual perspectives, the book explores the messy reality of reconciliation, the tension between religious upbringing and personal questioning, and the weight of keeping secrets for those we love. While it handles mature themes like near-death experiences and teenage relationships, it does so with a grounded, empathetic tone that validates the intensity of adolescent emotions. It is an excellent choice for fostering discussions about forgiveness and the courage required to admit when we are wrong.
Characters struggle with keeping secrets and the ethics of honesty versus protection.
A character nearly drowns and describes a near-death experience.
Depictions of teenage dating and physical intimacy (non-explicit).
Themes of grief, broken friendships, and the aftermath of a traumatic event.
The book deals directly with a near-death experience and the psychological trauma following it. It also addresses religious deconstruction (secular vs. Christian viewpoints) and sexual assault (past trauma involving a secondary character). The approach is realistic and heavy, but the resolution is hopeful and focuses on healing through truth.
A high schooler who feels isolated by their changing beliefs or someone who has lost a close friend over a misunderstanding and doesn't know how to initiate the apology.
Parents should be aware of a subplot involving a character's past experience with sexual assault. It is handled with care but is a significant plot point. A parent might see their teen pulling away from their childhood faith or witnessing a sudden, cold end to a long-term friendship.
Younger teens (14) will focus on the romance and the drama of the friendship rift. Older teens (17-18) will likely resonate more with the existential questioning and the anxiety of transitioning out of high school.
Unlike many YA novels that treat religion as a background detail or a villain, this book centers on the internal conflict of a girl trying to reconcile her faith with her reality.
Hannah and Emory were inseparable until a massive falling out left them in a months-long silence. When Emory's boyfriend, Luke, nearly dies in an accident, Hannah is the one who saves him. The aftermath forces all three characters to navigate a new reality. Luke is haunted by a near-death vision, Hannah is questioning her strict religious upbringing, and Emory is desperate to cling to a 'normal' that no longer exists. The narrative alternates between the girls, eventually revealing the traumatic event involving Hannah's brother that caused their rift.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review