
A parent might reach for this book when their teenager is navigating the intensity of a first romance or feeling the weight of strict family expectations. It is an ideal choice for families discussing how to balance personal identity with religious or cultural traditions. The story follows Devorah, a Hasidic girl, and Jaxon, a secular Black boy, who meet during a hospital elevator mishap in Brooklyn. As they fall in love, they must grapple with the profound consequences of defying their communities. While the romance is central, the book deeply explores themes of independence and the courage required to question the status quo. It contains some profanity and depictions of physical intimacy, making it most suitable for mature high schoolers who are ready to process complex social and religious dynamics.
Characters are trapped in an elevator during a power outage/storm.
Includes descriptions of physical intimacy and a scene where the characters have sex.
Themes of estrangement from family and the pain of leaving one's faith community.
The book deals directly with religious isolation, the book depicts instances of prejudice between the Hasidic and Black communities, and the loss of community. The approach is realistic and deeply grounded in the specific traditions of the Hasidic community. The resolution is bittersweet and ambiguous, avoiding a fairy-tale ending in favor of a more grounded, life-altering choice.
A 16-year-old who feels like an outsider in their own home or church, or a teen reader who enjoys high-stakes contemporary romance with significant cultural substance.
Parents should be aware of a scene involving sexual intimacy and the use of some profanity. Parents may want to familiarize themselves with the history of interactions between the Hasidic and Black communities in Crown Heights, as the book touches on historical tensions and disparities in resources. A parent might see their teen pulling away from family traditions, keeping secrets about who they are spending time with, or expressing frustration with restrictive household rules.
Younger teens (14) may focus on the 'forbidden love' trope and the excitement of the secret meetings. Older teens (17-18) will better appreciate the heavy cost of leaving one's community and the complex nuances of religious faith versus religious structure.
Unlike many 'star-crossed' stories, this book uses a specific New York City geography to highlight how two people can live on the same street yet remain completely invisible to one another until a crisis occurs.
Devorah is a strictly observant Hasidic teen in Crown Heights, while Jaxon is a secular Black teen living just blocks away but in a different world. After a chance encounter during a hurricane, they begin a clandestine relationship that forces them to choose between their budding love and the families they have always known.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review