
Reach for this book when your child is beginning to experiment with white lies or is struggling to understand the ripple effects of being untruthful. While the stakes of a growing nose are fantastical, the social embarrassment and the frantic need to cover up one lie with another are deeply relatable to elementary-aged children. This story provides a low-pressure way to discuss why honesty is often the easier path in the long run. In this sixteenth installment of the Whatever After series, siblings Abby and Jonah travel into the story of Pinocchio. Chaos ensues when the wooden puppet follows them back to the real world. As they try to hide a magical puppet in their modern school, they face the humorous and stressful reality of maintaining a massive secret. It is a lighthearted, fast-paced adventure that uses magic to mirror the very real anxiety kids feel when they aren't being fully honest.
Characters face the threat of a giant shark and magical transformations.
The book handles the concept of dishonesty through a secular, metaphorical lens. The consequences are physical (the nose) and social (losing trust). There is a brief mention of the classic shark/whale peril, which is resolved through teamwork and quick thinking. The tone remains humorous and hopeful throughout.
A 7 to 10 year old who enjoys fractured fairy tales and slapstick humor, specifically a child who might be feeling the pressure of trying to fit in or hiding a mistake from their parents or teachers.
The book is a safe, independent read. No heavy lifting is required from parents, though it serves as an excellent springboard for a casual conversation about why 'covering your tracks' is more exhausting than telling the truth. A parent might choose this after catching their child in a circular lie or noticing their child is stressed about a secret they are keeping from friends at school.
Younger readers will focus on the slapstick humor of the growing nose and the magic mirror. Older readers (9-11) will resonate more with Abby's social anxiety and the logistical difficulty of maintaining a false narrative in a school setting.
Unlike the darker original Collodi tale or the moralizing Disney version, Mlynowski places the 'honesty' lesson in a modern, relatable middle-school context, making the consequences feel social rather than just punitive.
Abby and Jonah fall through their magic mirror into the story of Pinocchio. Their mission is to get Pinocchio to school, but the puppet is more interested in mischief. When Pinocchio accidentally follows them back to their modern-day home, the siblings must navigate their own school day while hiding a wooden boy whose nose grows with every lie. They eventually find the Blue Fairy to set things right and return Pinocchio to his own story.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review