
Reach for this book when your child is navigating the pressure of performing for others or struggling with the ethics of 'capturing' a moment versus living it. This quiet, thoughtful story follows Lucy as she moves to a lakeside house and enters a photography contest judged by her own professional photographer father. It is a beautiful exploration of artistic integrity and the realization that being a good observer sometimes means knowing when to put the camera down. Parents will appreciate the nuanced handling of Lucy's desire for her father's approval and her growing awareness of other people's vulnerabilities. It is ideal for middle-grade readers who are sensitive, creative, or currently navigating the complexities of new friendships and family expectations. The story provides a gentle roadmap for honesty and empathy in art and life.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewDepicts a grandmother's gradual memory loss and the family's emotional reaction to it.
The book deals with aging and cognitive decline (dementia/Alzheimer's) in a realistic and secular manner. The resolution is bittersweet but hopeful, focusing on acceptance and the dignity of the elderly rather than a cure.
A thoughtful 10-year-old who loves nature and art, particularly one who feels a bit overlooked by a busy or talented parent and is looking for their own voice.
Read the scenes involving Nate's grandmother and the 'shameful' photo Lucy takes. It is a great moment to discuss privacy and the power of imagery. The book can be read cold. A parent might notice their child becoming hyper-focused on 'likes' or external validation for their hobbies, or perhaps a child who has been caught sharing something private about a friend.
Younger readers (age 8-9) will focus on the loons, the lake, and the fun of the scavenger hunt. Older readers (11-12) will deeply feel the weight of Lucy's ethical dilemma regarding her father and the contest.
Unlike many 'new kid' stories, this focuses heavily on the ethics of the gaze: what does it mean to look at someone, and what do we owe the people we photograph?
Lucy moves to New Hampshire and befriends her neighbor, Nate. Together, they explore the lake and track a pair of loons. Lucy enters a photography contest anonymously, which is being judged by her father, hoping to prove her talent without his bias. As she captures the world through her lens, she realizes that some of her best photos might actually hurt the people she cares about, specifically Nate's grandmother, who is struggling with memory loss.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.