
A parent might reach for this book when their middle schooler is feeling deep shame or embarrassment about their family's circumstances, whether due to financial struggles, a relative's mental illness, or simply feeling different. Edgewater follows Lorrie, who lives in a crumbling mansion with her reclusive, hoarding aunt. She desperately tries to hide her reality from her peers, especially a new, wealthy friend named Charlie. But as she uncovers a mystery connecting their two families, she learns that even the most perfect-seeming lives have dark secrets. This gripping mystery for ages 11-14 is an excellent choice for normalizing complex feelings about family and social pressure, showing that everyone has a story and that truth is more powerful than shame.
Includes some kissing and sweet, age-appropriate romantic feelings.
Deals with parental absence and a guardian's severe mental illness (hoarding, agoraphobia).
The book deals directly with mental illness (Aunt Gigi's agoraphobia, hoarding, and paranoia) and its impact on a child caregiver. The approach is secular and empathetic. It also touches on socioeconomic disparity and the emotional weight of family secrets. The resolution is hopeful and realistic; not all problems are perfectly solved, but Lorrie finds acceptance and a path forward. The disappearance of a parent is a central plot point.
A sensitive 12 to 14 year old who is acutely aware of social hierarchies and feels "less than" because of their family's situation (financial, mental health, or just perceived weirdness). This is for the child who tries to hide their home life from friends and feels a constant, low-grade anxiety about being "found out."
Parents should be prepared to discuss mental illness, particularly hoarding and agoraphobia, as portrayed through Aunt Gigi. The concept of a child acting as a caregiver might be a good point of discussion. The mystery involves some mature elements like a past affair and a presumed death. The book can be read cold, but a post-reading conversation about the themes would be valuable. A parent overhears their child lying to a friend about where they live, what their parents do, or deflecting questions about their home life. The parent might notice their child is isolating themselves or seems burdened by a family situation they feel they must keep secret.
A younger reader (11-12) will likely focus on the mystery and the budding romance with Charlie. They will grasp the core feeling of embarrassment. An older reader (13-14) will connect more deeply with the psychological nuances: the weight of being a young caregiver, the complexity of Gigi's mental state, and the critique of societal pressures to appear "perfect."
Among books on family secrets, Edgewater uniquely blends a classic gothic mystery feel (the crumbling mansion as a character) with a contemporary and realistic portrayal of a teen dealing with a guardian's mental illness and the accompanying shame. The compelling mystery plot serves as the engine for the emotional journey, making it more accessible than a straightforward "problem novel."
Lorrie Hollander lives in the dilapidated Edgewater mansion with her agoraphobic and hoarding aunt, Gigi. Ashamed of her home and unconventional family, she tries to keep it secret, especially from Charlie, the handsome son of a senator who likes her. As their relationship develops, Lorrie discovers that Charlie's seemingly perfect family has its own dark secrets, which are mysteriously linked to Edgewater and the disappearance of Lorrie's mother years ago. The story is a mystery that unfolds through Lorrie's investigation into both families' pasts.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review