
A parent would reach for this book when their child begins noticing social injustices or when the family is navigating the complex emotional terrain of adoption and community belonging. It is a powerful tool for discussing the difference between intentions and impact, especially regarding racial prejudice. The story follows the Fickett family as they adopt Edgar Allan, a Black toddler, and face a wave of hostility from their town and even within their own home. It explores themes of moral courage, the pain of social rejection, and the difficult reality that love is not always enough to shield someone from systemic hate. While it is written for ages 10 to 14, the realistic and sometimes heartbreaking ending provides a vital opportunity to discuss why standing up for what is right is necessary even when it is difficult.
The family ultimately gives the child back, which may be traumatic for some readers.
Threatening phone calls and vandalism create a climate of fear.
The book deals directly with racism, hate crimes, and the failure of adults to protect vulnerable children. The approach is realistic and secular. The resolution is famously ambiguous and somber, avoiding a fairy tale ending in favor of a cautionary tale about the cost of cowardice.
A thoughtful middle schooler who is starting to question the fairness of the world or a child in a family discussing the ethics of social activism and the realities of prejudice.
Parents should definitely read the final chapters beforehand. The decision to return Edgar Allan is controversial and can be upsetting for children who expect a heroic ending. Parents may want to be prepared to discuss the historical context of racial prejudice in the 1960s, including the Civil Rights Movement and the specific forms of discrimination Black families faced in suburban communities at that time. A parent might notice their child feeling disillusioned by unfairness at school or asking why 'good people' sometimes let bad things happen. The trigger is the realization that justice is not always served.
Younger readers (10) may focus on the sadness of losing a sibling, while older readers (13-14) will likely grapple with the father's moral compromise and the systemic nature of the town's racism.
Unlike many books on this topic, Edgar Allan does not have a happy ending. It is a rare, honest look at the consequences of failing to stand up to hate. """
Narrated by twelve year old Michael, the story chronicles the Fickett family's attempt to adopt a toddler named Edgar Allan in a conservative community. The family faces external threats, including a burning cross and anonymous calls, alongside internal pressure from the oldest daughter, Mary Nell, who issues an ultimatum. Ultimately, the father decides to return the child to the agency, leading to a tragic dissolution of the family's moral center.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review