
Reach for this book when your child is starting to navigate complex social dynamics where someone uses their vulnerability or hardship to control others. While it is set during the 1950s polio epidemic, the core of the story is about the painful realization that a person facing a terrible illness can still be manipulative or even cruel. It is a sophisticated look at empathy versus pity, and the importance of maintaining one's own boundaries. Eleven-year-old Georgie is fascinated by her new neighbor, Phyllis, a beautiful teenager confined to an iron lung. However, as Georgie and her brother are drawn into Phyllis's world, they discover a web of deception and psychological games. This is an excellent choice for mature middle-schoolers (ages 10-14) who are ready for a realistic, slightly darker look at human nature and the historical realities of disability.
Moments of medical urgency and the threat of power outages for the iron lung.
Depicts the stark reality of living in an iron lung and the fear of a pandemic.
The approach is starkly realistic and avoids the 'inspirational' trope. The resolution is realistic and somewhat bittersweet: truth prevails, but at the cost of innocence.
A thoughtful 12-year-old who enjoys historical fiction and is beginning to notice that 'being nice' and 'being good' are not the same thing. This is for the child who enjoys decoding social cues and power dynamics.
Parents should be aware of the intense imagery of the iron lung and the psychological cruelty Phyllis exhibits. No specific pages need skipping, but a conversation about manipulation is helpful. A parent might notice their child struggling with a 'toxic' friendship where the other child uses guilt or a personal problem to get their way.
Younger readers (10) will focus on the scary nature of the disease and the 1950s setting. Older readers (13-14) will better grasp the nuance of Phyllis's character and the danger of her emotional manipulation.
Unlike most books about illness which focus on the patient's bravery, this book explores the patient as a complex, potentially villainous human being, making it a rare and vital study in moral ambiguity. """
Set in Indiana in 1952, Georgie and her brother Emmett deal with the heat and fear of a polio summer. They meet Phyllis, a teenager paralyzed by polio who lives in an iron lung. While the community views Phyllis as a tragic figure, she is actually a masterful manipulator who uses her condition to weave lies that threaten to tear Georgie's family and friendships apart.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review