
Reach for this book when your child starts questioning the idea of 'heroes' or is beginning to realize that public figures can be deeply flawed. While many biographies for this age group offer a polished version of history, James Cross Giblin provides a nuanced, honest look at Charles Lindbergh. It balances his legendary solo flight across the Atlantic with the harrowing kidnapping of his son and his controversial political stances later in life. This is a vital resource for older children (ages 10-14) who are ready to move past black-and-white thinking. It explores complex themes of perseverance and accomplishment alongside heavy subjects like grief and moral ambiguity. Parents will appreciate the way it introduces the idea that one can achieve great things while also making significant, even harmful, mistakes. It is an excellent tool for building critical thinking and empathy.
Challenges the reader to reconcile Lindbergh's bravery with his controversial politics.
Themes of grief, public scrutiny, and the loss of a child.
The book deals with the kidnapping and death of the Lindbergh baby directly and realistically, including the media circus that followed. It also addresses Lindbergh's anti-Semitic comments and pro-German sympathies during WWII. The approach is secular and objective, presenting facts without sanitizing them, leading to a realistic and somewhat ambiguous resolution regarding his character.
A middle-schooler who is a history buff or aviation enthusiast, but more importantly, a student who is beginning to engage with complex social studies topics and needs a model for how to evaluate historical figures critically.
Parents should preview the chapters regarding the kidnapping (for emotional intensity) and the pre-WWII years (to be ready to discuss Lindbergh's anti-Semitism and the context of the 1930s). A parent might notice their child struggling with 'cancel culture' or the realization that a favorite historical figure held views they find abhorrent.
Younger readers (10) will focus on the aviation and the 'detective' aspect of the kidnapping. Older readers (13-14) will be more captivated by the moral questions surrounding Lindbergh's political choices and the ethics of celebrity.
Unlike many 'Step into Reading' or highly sanitized biographies, Giblin does not shy away from the 'unheroic' parts of Lindbergh's life, making it a rare example of a balanced biography for the middle-grade audience.
The book chronicles the life of Charles Lindbergh, beginning with his early fascination with flight and his record-breaking 1927 solo flight from New York to Paris in the Spirit of St. Louis. It then transitions into his private life, detailing his marriage to Anne Morrow and the tragic kidnapping and death of their first child. The final third of the book tackles his isolationist views, his involvement with the America First Committee, and his complicated legacy in American history.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review